Howard Butler wrote:
I need GEOS for Touches/Disjoint (topology operations) anyway, so extra
dependencies are not a help, rather the opposite.
Indexing is orthogonal to GEOS main geometry algebra operations, IMO. I don't
like that we expose internal indexing stuff publicly because it will limit the
library's options to do something different in the future. That it uses an
index to do things internally for things like prepared geometry is an
implementation detail. Small pieces, loosely joined, not giant monoliths (/me
stares in GDAL's embedding-every-library-in-the-entire-osgis-ecosystem's
direction). I understand the desire to not have extra dependencies, but if you
want a general, programmable rtree, GEOS' isn't it at this time.
To the GEOS devs, is GEOS to be an indexing library too?
Sure, why not? At least for in-memory indexes - there are no plans to
extend this to disk-based indexes.
Reasons are:
i) The code is there and well-tested
ii) The index is designed to work well with GEOS objects (although as
you point out, indexes are fairly independent)
iii) This reduces the need for dependencies on other librarries (as I
think you have just recommended)
Of course as you say this exposes an interface which will need to be
maintained in the future. But there's a fairly low cost to maintaining
the simple indexes currently provided (and there are no current plans to
stop using them in GEOS itself).
All I need is to identify which bounding boxes (envelopes in GEOM-speak)
intersect for a fixed set of objects whose bounding boxes I can compute, and
where GEOS is already present and running.
Doesn't GEOS' prepared geometry stuff already do this, or is that not
sufficient? Maybe I don't understand the problem well enough.
PreparedGeometry optimizes the computation between two individual
geometries, but it doesn't optimize the situation of processing two sets
of geometries in pairwise fashion. For that you need a spatial index.
--
Martin Davis
Senior Technical Architect
Refractions Research, Inc.
(250) 383-3022
_______________________________________________
geos-devel mailing list
geos-devel@lists.osgeo.org
http://lists.osgeo.org/mailman/listinfo/geos-devel
