2009/3/7 Webb Sprague <[email protected]>

> I don't know if they have been tested in the courts, but there are a
> plethora of Gnu license agreements out there that should fit the bill.
>  No one would mind someone agreeing to indemnify you.  Is there no Gnu
> license contract for data?
>

GPL is a copyright-based mechanism, and copyright is generally not
applicable to a collection of facts in North America.  The use of Creative
Commons and GPL for geodata is problematic here.  That doesn't stop many
organisations from claiming copyright on their data.

I really like the open database license, and am encouraged to see that
additional work is being done on it. It's still in beta, but hopefully only
for a few more weeks!

http://www.opendatacommons.org/licenses/odbl/

There are other open data options, such as PDDL combined with community
norms:

http://www.opendatacommons.org/licenses/

And CC0 is another alternative:

http://wiki.creativecommons.org/CC0

This is all really new.  A year ago, the options for publishing data under
license were limited and confusing.  I hope that this work allows us to
standardise on a few easy-to-understand licenses that allow for open sharing
while minimising risk.

All I want from any data provider is an ftp source with shapefiles in
> zip bundles, and for them to get  the prj files is right.  This
> doesn't really take much staff, though, yes, it takes some.
>

Anyone publishing their data openly needs to consider the effects of
choosing a single (semi-)proprietary format.  I'm not convinced that our
residents are best served by publishing for the benfit a small set of GIS
power users, rather than targetting an open format that is accessibly by
users of all skill levels (such as KML).  I'm pretty sure that most people
wouldn't know what to do with a .shp file.  Or a FTP site for that matter :)

Jason
_______________________________________________
Geowanking mailing list
[email protected]
http://geowanking.org/mailman/listinfo/geowanking_geowanking.org

Reply via email to