The last one, I promess! 2011/11/28 Bogdan Szczurek <thebod...@gmail.com>:
>> Keeping RGB using colors that fit inside the gamuts of all the devices >> involved for the essential colors (for instance branding colors) give >> you a good balance of color preservation and color reliability. > > That "common gamut" is one example of lowest common denominator I meant. I don't agree. it's an example of knowing your outputs and acting in consecuence choosing the best combination available to minimize errors. >> I don't think it's necessary to sacrifice the color richness of a >> photography to the lowest common denominator for every intended >> output, and afaik that's what you do when switch your assets to CMYK >> at the beginning of the pipe. > > I switch them "at the end" leaving "sources" intact (it proved to be right > way many times). I also use that method many times. That's what I know as "Intermediate Binding" and I agree that most of times it's the safest choice. Best of both worlds. And intermediate binding is more or less possible with GIMP (using Separate+ or CMYKtool). I proposed some time ago some enhancements to Separate+ to address specific examples like the one you pointed out (rich black) and other specific situations where primaries end up used more or less like spot channels. I agree there's a sort of gap there in late binding. >> I did some tests sendind the same files to different providers both in >> RGB and CMYK to see what happened. Comparing the samples I find RGB >> more even accross providers. > > So, RGB images were reproduced more consistently? Yes, they did. I guess I can blame the poor CM skills of the people who printed the samples, but it was a real world case and RGB gave better results when the provider asked for generic profiles instead of sending a custom profile. I guess that having a custom profile I would have received pretty much the same sending RGB or CMYK. Gez. P.s.: It was worth it, indeed. ;-) _______________________________________________ gimp-developer-list mailing list gimp-developer-list@gnome.org http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/gimp-developer-list
