>  this only selects the current word.

Ok, it only selects, agree your op said that, but I misunderstood due to the 
strength of the preconception that ctrl-c copies.  Shows what the power of that 
expectation is.

Agree with @ntrel that there are other adjacent keybindings with risks, but 
ctrl-c/v is likely _the_ most common.

Agree with @b4n that the suggested behaviour is confusing.

A quick survey of what the editors/IDEs I have here (Linux) do on ctrl-c 
without any selection:

- Vscode: copies line ... eeek!!!  bet this is where the idea for all the 
requests comes from
- Eclipse: does nothing
- Gedit: does nothing
- Xed: does nothing
- Scite: does nothing
- this github window: does nothing
- emacs: does nothing, well actually without selection its a command prefix, 
but its copy with a selection, ahhh emacs ;-P

Adding unusual behaviour to common actions is a user trap, even if its safe 
behaviour (just select) its likely to be confusing.  And selecting it looks 
like the word was copied, but its not.

Whilst the select word keybinding is awkward (its three key left hand only), if 
you use it enough for it to be a significant hindrance to your workflow you can 
re-define it to another binding in preferences.  And of course select word is 
double click too.

Better not tinker with the behaviour of one of the most common user actions.

-- 
Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub:
https://github.com/geany/geany/pull/3391#issuecomment-1426503252
You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.

Message ID: <geany/geany/pull/3391/c1426503...@github.com>

Reply via email to