github  

Messages by Date

• 2026/10/19 Re: [I] The PostCommit Java ValidatesRunner Dataflow Streaming job is flaky [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [I] The PreCommit SQL Java17 job is flaky [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [Python] Add Qdrant search enrichment handler [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 [I] The PerformanceTests SpannerIO Write 2GB Python Batch job is flaky [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [Python] Fail bundles on state write errors [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [Iceberg CDC source] Allow dropping PK or watermark columns [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Update api key for tour of beam [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [Prism] Keep a stateful key in progress while a split primary holds it [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Process deletes before adds when committing OrderedList state updates. [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [I] [Feature Request]: Support for iceberg dynamic destination with varying schema [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Add OpenTelemetry tracing support to SolaceIO [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [yaml] - add openai model handler [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Process deletes before adds when committing OrderedList state updates. [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [I] [Feature Request]: Add a basic doc explaining Beam's security model [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 [PR] Process deletes before adds when committing OrderedList state updates. [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Modernize legacy DoFn in BatchElementsExample (#40557) [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [Multikey] [Dataflow Streaming] Replace KeyGroupWorkQueue with a sharded KeyGroupIndex [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [I] [Bug]: [RunInference] Pipelines using ModelHandlers with max_batch_weight fail at construction time [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Add OpenTelemetry tracing support to SolaceIO [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [WriteFiles] Support direct writes of large streaming bundles to temp files (#40533) [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [KafkaIO] Advance idle partition watermark without requiring a record [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 [PR] Document Beam Playground security model and result caching [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [I] Non-transient non-serializable instance field in WatermarkHold [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Only feed total memory readings to the ModelManager resource estimator [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [KafkaIO] Advance idle partition watermark without requiring a record [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Only feed total memory readings to the ModelManager resource estimator [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 [PR] [yaml] - add openai model handler [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [Spark 4] Group the streaming stateful ParDo by encoded key bytes to support null keys [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Remove a race with another file write that is not essential to test presence of duplicates. [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Update api key for tour of beam [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [I] [Feature Request]: Add a basic doc explaining Beam's security model [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [I] The PostCommit Java PVR Flink Batch job is flaky [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Run portable ValidatesRunner tests one at a time [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [I] Non-transient non-serializable instance field in WatermarkHold [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [IcebergIO] Support sorted writes and RANGE distribution mode [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Fix postgres database for grafana [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Update users.yml [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 [PR] Fix postgres database for grafana [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 [PR] Update api key for tour of beam [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 [PR] Update users.yml [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] fix: allow empty DynamoDB list and map in AttributeValueCoder [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Update users.yml [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Auto-infer BigQuery schema from schema'd PCollections for FILE_LOADS [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Add Bigtable CDC YAML SchemaTransform [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [Dataflow Streaming] Reduce contention on CommitQueue [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [Iceberg compaction] Add committer DoFn [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [Dataflow Streaming] Reduce contention on CommitQueue [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [I] [Feature Request]: Add a basic doc explaining Beam's security model [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [I] [Feature Request]: Add a basic doc explaining Beam's security model [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Invalidate cached ContinuationIterable when its continuation fails [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [Iceberg compaction] Rewrite subgroups DoFn [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [Iceberg compaction] Rewrite subgroups DoFn [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [KafkaIO] Advance idle partition watermark without requiring a record [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Run portable ValidatesRunner tests one at a time [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Bump github/codeql-action from 4.38.3 to 4.39.0 [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Bump google.golang.org/api from 0.302.0 to 0.304.0 in /sdks [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 [PR] [IcebergIO] Support sorted writes and RANGE distribution mode [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [IcebergIO] Support sorted writes and RANGE distribution mode (#38406) [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [BEAM-19954] Resolve string annotations in callable type hints [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [Go SDK] Return job message id from WaitForCompletion [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Fix temp table cleanup for continuous read in BigQueryIO [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [I] [Failing Test]: Flink 1.20 portable DataSet ValidatesRunner tests hang [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [I] [Bug]: SolaceIO write transform does not output all publish results [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [I] [Bug]: SolaceIO write transform does not output all publish results [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [IcebergIO] Support sorted writes and RANGE distribution mode [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [Spark 4] Group the streaming stateful ParDo by encoded key bytes to support null keys [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Run portable ValidatesRunner tests one at a time [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [Multikey] [Dataflow Streaming] Replace KeyGroupWorkQueue with a sharded KeyGroupIndex [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [Spanner Change Streams] Match single-RPC deadline to total timeout in SpannerIO.ReadChangeStream [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] [Python] Support Protobuf 7.x [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Add Bigtable CDC YAML SchemaTransform [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/19 Re: [PR] Update FlareDB runner doc [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [PR] Add Bigtable CDC YAML SchemaTransform [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [PR] Add Bigtable CDC YAML SchemaTransform [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [PR] Add Bigtable CDC YAML SchemaTransform [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [PR] Bump zizmorcore/zizmor-action from 0.6.4 to 0.7.1 [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [PR] Bump google.golang.org/api from 0.302.0 to 0.304.0 in /sdks [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [PR] Bump github/codeql-action from 4.38.3 to 4.39.0 [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 [PR] Bump zizmorcore/zizmor-action from 0.6.4 to 0.7.1 [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 [PR] Bump google.golang.org/api from 0.302.0 to 0.304.0 in /sdks [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 [PR] Bump github/codeql-action from 4.38.3 to 4.39.0 [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [I] [Feature Request]: Set quota project in `beam.io.ReadFromBigQuery` [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [PR] Bump minimum cryptography bounds beyond known severe CVEs [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [PR] [Python] Preserve HTTP errors for non-JSON quota responses [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [I] [Bug]: Quota retry filter masks non-JSON HTTP 403 errors [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [PR] [Python] Merge runtime type-check wrappers [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [PR] Support attributing BigQuery quota and billing to a custom GCP project (Python, Java, Go) [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [PR] [Python] Merge runtime type-check wrappers [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [PR] [Go SDK] Fix generic registration of anonymous struct types [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 [PR] [Go SDK] Fix generic registration of anonymous struct types [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [I] [Bug]: Go SDK registration panics on anonymous structs. [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [PR] [DoNotMerge] Adds CouchbaseIO, a Java connector for Couchbase Server. Fixes #18381 [DonNotMerge] [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 [PR] Adds CouchbaseIO, a Java connector for Couchbase Server. Fixes #18381. [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [PR] [Python] Only give an unknown option a value that directly follows it [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 [PR] [Python] Only give an unknown option a value that directly follows it [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [I] [Bug]: retain_unknown_options incorrectly assumes unknown arguments are consecutive [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [I] [Failing Test]: portable_runner_test in Python SDK [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [I] [Bug]: Python Enrichment BigQuery handler does not expose `max_batch_duration_secs` to `BatchElements` [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [I] [Bug]: Python Enrichment BigQuery handler does not expose `max_batch_duration_secs` to `BatchElements` [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [PR] [DO NOT MERGE] compaction wip [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/18 Re: [PR] [DO NOT MERGE] compaction wip [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/17 Re: [I] Non-transient non-serializable instance field in WatermarkHold [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/17 Re: [I] Non-transient non-serializable instance field in WatermarkHold [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/17 Re: [PR] [Python] Add Qdrant search enrichment handler [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/17 Re: [PR] [Go SDK] Add portable logical type registration and standard date and micros_instant types [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/17 Re: [PR] [Go SDK] Add portable logical type registration and standard date and micros_instant types [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/17 Re: [PR] [Python] Fail bundles on state write errors [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/17 Re: [PR] [Python] Keep BigQuery load jobs distinct for table aliases [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/17 Re: [PR] Only feed total memory readings to the ModelManager resource estimator [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/17 Re: [PR] Only feed total memory readings to the ModelManager resource estimator [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/17 [PR] Only feed total memory readings to the ModelManager resource estimator [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/17 Re: [PR] Fix Windows paths for Dataflow job files [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/17 Re: [I] [Task]: Improve the schema support [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/17 Re: [PR] WIP [Rust SDK] Add the Cargo workspace, Gradle integration and model crate [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/17 Re: [PR] Fix Windows paths for Dataflow job files [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/17 Re: [PR] [Java][BigQueryIO] Avoid reflective lookup in unknown-column collectors [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/17 Re: [PR] Document required Go SDK initialization [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/17 Re: [I] [Failing Test]: Flink 1.20 portable DataSet ValidatesRunner tests hang [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/17 [I] [Failing Test]: Flink 1.20 portable DataSet ValidatesRunner tests hang [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/17 Re: [PR] Run portable ValidatesRunner tests one at a time [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/17 Re: [PR] Document required Go SDK initialization [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/17 Re: [PR] Run portable ValidatesRunner tests one at a time [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] WIP [Rust SDK] Add the Cargo workspace, Gradle integration and model crate [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] WIP [Rust SDK] Add the Cargo workspace, Gradle integration and model crate [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [I] [Bug]: [RunInference] Pipelines using ModelHandlers with max_batch_weight fail at construction time [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Prism] Finalize bundles of DoFns fused after another transform [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [I] [Bug]: [RunInference] Pipelines using ModelHandlers with max_batch_weight fail at construction time [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [typescript] - fix typescript failures [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] WIP [Rust SDK] Add the Cargo workspace, Gradle integration and model crate [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Dataflow Streaming] Speed up non-portable worker precommit tests [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Java SDK harness] Prevent a Fn data plane deadlock in BeamFnDataGrpcMultiplexer [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Java SDK harness] Prevent a Fn data plane deadlock in BeamFnDataGrpcMultiplexer [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Java SDK harness] Prevent a Fn data plane deadlock in BeamFnDataGrpcMultiplexer [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Java SDK harness] Prevent a Fn data plane deadlock in BeamFnDataGrpcMultiplexer [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Java SDK harness] Prevent a Fn data plane deadlock in BeamFnDataGrpcMultiplexer [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [I] [Bug]: [RunInference] Pipelines using ModelHandlers with max_batch_weight fail at construction time [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Prism] Finalize bundles of DoFns fused after another transform [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [I] [Bug]: [RunInference] Pipelines using ModelHandlers with max_batch_weight fail at construction time [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Prism] Finalize bundles of DoFns fused after another transform [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [I] [Bug]: [RunInference] Pipelines using ModelHandlers with max_batch_weight fail at construction time [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 [I] [Bug]: [RunInference] Pipelines using ModelHandlers with max_batch_by_weight fail at construction time [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [BEAM-19954] Resolve string annotations in callable type hints [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Python] Preserve HTTP errors for non-JSON quota responses [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Java SDK harness] Prevent a Fn data plane deadlock in BeamFnDataGrpcMultiplexer [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Java SDK harness] Prevent a Fn data plane deadlock in BeamFnDataGrpcMultiplexer [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Java SDK harness] Prevent a Fn data plane deadlock in BeamFnDataGrpcMultiplexer [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Java SDK harness] Prevent a Fn data plane deadlock in BeamFnDataGrpcMultiplexer [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Java SDK harness] Prevent a Fn data plane deadlock in BeamFnDataGrpcMultiplexer [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Java SDK harness] Prevent a Fn data plane deadlock in BeamFnDataGrpcMultiplexer [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Java SDK harness] Prevent a Fn data plane deadlock in BeamFnDataGrpcMultiplexer [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] Update nlp_tensorflow_streaming.ipynb [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 [I] Performance Regression or Improvement: gbk_python_batch_load_test_2gb_of_100KB_records:runtime [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 [I] Performance Regression or Improvement: combine_python_batch_2gb_10_byte_records:runtime [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Spark 4] Clear the watermark of keys without timers or state in the streaming stateful ParDo [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] Update nlp_tensorflow_streaming.ipynb [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 [PR] Update nlp_tensorflow_streaming.ipynb [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] Adds bytes read reporting for SDF. [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 [PR] [Python] Add Qdrant search enrichment handler [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Java SDK harness] Prevent a Fn data plane deadlock in BeamFnDataGrpcMultiplexer [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] Adds bytes read reporting for SDF. [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Java SDK harness] Prevent a Fn data plane deadlock in BeamFnDataGrpcMultiplexer [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [I] [Feature Request][RunInference] Support multi-model KeyedModelHandler with ModelManager [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Java SDK harness] Prevent a Fn data plane deadlock in BeamFnDataGrpcMultiplexer [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Prism] Finalize bundles of DoFns fused after another transform [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 [PR] [Prism] Finalize bundles of DoFns fused after another transform [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [I] [Bug]: [RunInference] _RunInferenceDoFn acquires acquires and releases models from ModelManager under different tags when a model is updated. [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Python] Fix max_models_per_worker_hint not being enforced in KeyedModelHandler [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Python] Fix max_models_per_worker_hint not being enforced in KeyedModelHandler [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [I] [Bug]: [RunInference] max_models_per_worker_hint is not enforced [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [BEAM-19954] Resolve string annotations in callable type hints [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Python] Fix max_models_per_worker_hint not being enforced in KeyedModelHandler [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Python] Fix max_models_per_worker_hint not being enforced in KeyedModelHandler [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Java SDK harness] Prevent a Fn data plane deadlock in BeamFnDataGrpcMultiplexer [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 [PR] Adds bytes read reporting for SDF. [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [typescript] - fix typescript failures [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [yaml] - fix post commit yaml test [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Python] Fix max_models_per_worker_hint not being enforced in KeyedModelHandler [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 [I] [Bug]: [RunInference] WatchFilePattern may fail to correctly identify the most recent model [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Python] Add examples for AWS credentials from a secret manager [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [I] [Bug]: [RunInference] WatchFilePattern may fail to correctly identify the most recent model [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [I] [Bug]: RunInference with automatic refresh using a global window side inputs takes too long to update sometimes [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [I] The PostCommit Java PVR Flink Batch job is flaky [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] Clarify known restrictions for model updates via side inputs. [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] Clarify known restrictions for model updates via side inputs. [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [I] [Task]: Use Timestamp logical type in Beam SQL [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 [PR] [Dataflow Streaming] Speed up non-portable worker precommit tests [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [Java SDK harness] Prevent a Fn data plane deadlock in BeamFnDataGrpcMultiplexer [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [RunInference] Reject use_model_manager with a multi-model KeyedModelHandler [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [I] [Failing Test]: portable_runner_test in Python SDK [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [BEAM-19954] Resolve string annotations in callable type hints [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] Remove a race with another file write that is not essential to test presence of duplicates. [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [BEAM-19954] Resolve string annotations in callable type hints [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] Add examples for AWS credentials from a secret manager [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [typescript] - fix typescript failures [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [BEAM-19954] Resolve string annotations in callable type hints [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [I] [Feature Request]: Add a Qdrant search enrichment handler for ml.rag [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] Remove a race with another file write that is not essential to test presence of duplicates. [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] Fix handling of cancelled tickets. [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [yaml] - fix post commit yaml test [beam] via GitHub
• 2026/10/16 Re: [PR] [yaml] - fix post commit yaml test [beam] via GitHub

• Earlier messages
• Later messages