On Sun, Oct 04, 2009 at 01:12:58PM -0400, Jefferson Kirkland wrote:
> While I am sure the Mac Mini is a nice machine, I can still get more machine
> for less.  Take a look at this
> machine<http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=9170835&type=product&id=1218043607320>at
> Best Buy.  As you can see, It has more of a procecssor, twice the
> ram, a slightly bigger hard drive and again, its less than half
> the price of a base Mac Mini.  If the didn't charge so much for
> their proprietary hardware, they might outsell the competition and
> beat them on price.

I'm hardly an Apple apologist (I don't even like MacOS, can't stand
the interface restrictions), but lets please try to be realistic
here.

The linked machine isn't even remotely comparable to a mini.
At 14.5x7.2x16.1, it is nearly 20 times the size of the mini.
Personally, I'd prefer the mini's dual-core intel processor to the
single core athlon in the linked machine.  The emachine draws more
power, so will cost more to run over the lifetime of the machine.
The mini includes firewire, wifi and bluetooth, the emachine does
not.  OTOH, the emachine comes with a keyboard and mouse, and has a
few available PCI-E slots, while the mini has none.

> I agree with Joseph's comment that they should get out of the hardware
> business and as a whole, concentrate on the OS and let people buy their own
> machines.  We, as consumers would certainly save some serious $$$ that way.

They've tried that a couple times that I can remember, and it never
worked out well.

A big part of the value of the Mac is that the hardware and software
are designed to work well together.  Letting people build their own
MacOS machines would lead either to the sort of driver compatability
hell that Windows has, or to a HCL that basically boils down to
"buy Apple hardware".  The first would lose one of Apple's few real
competitive advantages, the second isn't really any different than
what we've got now, but would increase Apple's support costs.

 -- mike

-- 
mwl+gnh...@alumni.unh.edu          OpenPGP KeyID 0x57C3430B
Holder of Past Knowledge           CS, O-
"As I walk in the Valley of the Shadow of Death, I think to myself,
 'This place obviously wasn't named by a real-estate developer.'"  Doug Finney

_______________________________________________
gnhlug-discuss mailing list
gnhlug-discuss@mail.gnhlug.org
http://mail.gnhlug.org/mailman/listinfo/gnhlug-discuss/

Reply via email to