Stevan -

Yes, I know your view on green leveraging gold - we have discussed it before.  
I accept your view is logical.  

But - and it is a big but - we are dealing with commercial publishers and 
commercial imperatives.  Why should the publishers reduce gold author pays 
charges if the academic community (especially the funders) are willing to pay?  
The evidence to date is that the academic community is willing to pay (although 
I accept the sample of gold channels is relatively small as yet).  Gold offers 
a seductively safe route for academics who object to high subscription charges 
and want maximum exposure of their work yet are unwilling to face up to the FUD 
(fear uncertainty and doubt) raised by the publishers concerning green OA.

I suspect the majority of a new generation of academics raised on social 
networking and web 2.0 will demand new models of scholarly communication beyond 
the existing subscription/green and author pays/gold models.  Like you I hope 
they separate the activities done by the community (authoring, reviewing, 
editing) from the management of peer review and find appropriate models for the 
latter - but I believe this will be within a new model of communication.

However, this is some way ahead.  Meantime - as you know - I support strongly 
green OA as you have defined it as the best mechanism we have today.  My 
objections to gold are based on increased cost for high output institutions and 
the danger of vanity publishing - there is a potential conflict of interest.  A 
further problem concerns associated data: it makes no sense to ship terabytes 
to publisher servers - much better to leave it as close as possible to the 
generating source, close to the expertise and context (this is where CERIF-CRIS 
come in) within which it was collected. BTW a similar argument goes for the 
benefit of institutional repositories of scholarly publications.

The problem - as you have documented well - is persuading the community.

Best
Keith

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Keith G Jeffery      Director International Relations       STFC
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The contents of this email are sent in confidence for the use of the intended 
recipient only.  If you are not one of the intended recipients do not take 
action on it or show it to anyone else, but return this email to the sender and 
delete your copy of it
The STFC telecommunications systems may be monitored in accordance with the 
policy available from 
<http://dlitd.dl.ac.uk/policy/monitoring/monitoring%20statement.htm>.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of 
Stevan Harnad
Sent: 07 May 2012 18:55
To: Global Open Access List (Successor of AmSci)
Subject: [GOAL] Re: Some discussion points for the UK OA initiative

On 2012-05-07, at 12:43 PM, <[email protected]> wrote:

> I do not believe Global Green would lead to Global Gold.  
> The motivations and business models behind each are too dissimilar - 
> as are the likely end-games.

The motivations need not be similar (and Green OA is not a business model).

Here's the end-game:

What the research community needs, urgently, today, is free online access (Open 
Access, OA) to its own peer-reviewed research output. 

Researchers can provide that in two ways:
by publishing their articles in OA journals (Gold OA) or by continuing to 
publish in non-OA journals and self-archiving their final peer-reviewed drafts 
in their own OA Institutional Repositories (Green OA). 

OA self-archiving (Green OA), once it is mandated by research institutions and 
funders, can reliably generate 100% Green OA. 

Gold OA requires journals to convert to OA publishing (which is not in the 
hands of the research community) and it also requires the funds to cover the 
Gold OA publication costs. With 100% Green OA, the research community's access 
and impact problems are already solved.

If and when 100% Green OA should cause significant cancellation pressure the 
cancellation pressure will cause cost-cutting, downsizing and eventually a 
leveraged transition to OA (Gold) publishing on the part of journals. 

As subscription revenues shrink, institutional windfall savings from 
cancellations grow. 

If and when journal subscriptions become unsustainable, per-article publishing 
costs will be low enough, and institutional savings will be high enough to 
cover them, because publishing will have downsized to just peer-review service 
provision alone, offloading text-generation onto authors and access-provision 
and archiving onto the global network of OA Institutional Repositories. 

Green OA will have leveraged a transition to Gold OA.

Harnad, S. (2007) The Green Road to Open Access: 
A Leveraged Transition. In: Anna Gacs. The Culture of Periodicals from the 
Perspective of the Electronic Age. 
L'Harmattan. 99-106. http://eprints.ecs.soton.ac.uk/13309/
_______________________________________________
GOAL mailing list
[email protected]
http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal
-- 
Scanned by iCritical.

_______________________________________________
GOAL mailing list
[email protected]
http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal

Reply via email to