On Tue, 31 Oct 2000, J.W.T.Smith wrote: > I would agree that one of the roles of the publisher is to organise > certification (I have argued this myself - elsewhere) but the publisher > currently also plays quality control (appearance, ie, copy-editing),
Correct. I used to make the distinction between quality-control for CONTENT (peer review) and quality control for FORM (editing). The picture is not very different either way. > making available, and marketing (making known) roles. I would like to predict (but nothing substantive rides on my prediction) that the "marketing role" is obsolete for refereed papers once they are online and free. The journal's QC/C tag and the Eprint Archives' free accessibility and navigability are all the "marketing" now needed for maximizing a paper's visibility and impact far beyond anything that was possible in the Gutenberg Era. > This is why my own suggested model for networked based publishing (the > Deconstructed Journal) > > http://library.ukc.ac.uk/library/papers/jwts/d-journal.htm > > is so much more complex (I think you described it as 'confused'). The above is an example of exactly the sort of untested peer-review/publication reform that I was criticizing in my posting. I am not criticizing the experiment, qua experiment on new forms of publication and peer review. (Otherwise how can such hypotheses ever be tested?) I am criticizing its relevance to the freeing of the current peer-reviewed literature, now: It is not an alternative way of freeing the current peer reviewed literature now (it is not even clear what kind of literature it will turn out to be), and representing it as such simply retards the freeing of the peer-reviewed literature, diverting efforts instead into untested, speculative directions. > I hold no brief for the preservation of the publisher and feel all the > roles played by the publisher could be played by others. In fact I think > that by preserving the ideas of the 'publisher' and 'journal' (albeit very > restricted interpretations of them) you are holding back the move to a > true network based form of academic publishing. We both seem to think the other one is holding something back. I at least can formulate what I think your approach is holding back: the freeing of the current peer-reviewed literature online, now. Why? Because that literature is currently peer-reviewed and published by journals. Regardless of what roles they or others might play in a hypothetical future, it is they who play those roles, now. And it is the literature they currently make accessible only through S/L/P that self-archiving is intended to free. There is no need to first free it from peer review, or from publishers. Your approach does require first freeing the literature from peer review and publishers. Well, to a first approximation (conditional on the eventual outcome of your experiment), that means we are no longer even talking about the same literature! I am talking about freeing the current, actual, refereed literature; you are talking about freeing a hypothetical future literature, no longer peer reviewed or published by the journals. Now who is holding what up? I, when I speak of our current peer-reviewed literature, and of the journals who peer-review it and the publishers who publish it, to be freed by self-archiving, now? Or you, when you speak of first eliminating publishers, and substituting new, untested mechanisms for tried and tested peer review? In my approach, it is crystal clear what all authors could do, today, to free the peer-reviewed literature completely tomorrow. What is the corresponding step in your approach? "Don't submit it to the journals, submit it to my 'Deconstructed Journals' instead." Suppose we suspend disbelief and imagine that every author were actually to do that, today (we must suppose also, counterfactually, that, like the eprints.org software, which is available for any institution to establish OAI-compliant Eprint Archives immediately, everywhere, "Deconstructed Journals" are likewise available in every field, ready to take the full submission load). Even supposing that (and also a satisfactory answer to my long unanswered question about the profligacy your proposal entails, in refereeing manpower and good will): What would be the result? What would the Deconstructed Journals produce as the end product (and when)? Would it be the same, peer-reviewed literature we have had till now, and wanted to liberate, or would it be something else, of whose quality we have no prior inkling? What would the researchers trying to use this literature rely on for the quality-control markers they used to have? What would promotion/tenure committees use? You may reply that if Deconstructed Journals DO prove to deliver the same quality that classical peer-reviewed journals did, then this will all sort itself out eventually. Eventually (and with a lot of hypotheses in between), perhaps. But MEANWHILE, who is holding things up, me or you? > The half-way house model of articles in archives still being 'published' > in journals (ie, certified by journals) leaves us still connected by an > umbilical cord to the old model with articles 'belonging' to journals > (although not in the strict sense they do now). The certification agencies > can distribute a list of the articles they have certified but take full > advantage of the fleibility of the network there also needs to be an extra > set of players who sort, sift and make known articles certified by others > (true 'overlays on the archives') and this actvity also needs a name. Is > it a journal? A para-journal (paralleling/parisiting)? I have a name for it: An untested hypothesis. I think we should instead back a sure thing. > Your model has no place for such an activity since it contains only > archives and certification agencies still called journals. Because I believe in calling a spade a spade -- and that if it ain't broke, don't fix it. > > So what do publishers have to do with peer review? Whether or not by > > historical accident, they are the ones, and the only ones, who have > > the track record in implementing it. > > As you say - historical accident - but why need this be perpetrated into > the future? Barbers used to also pull teeth but we have moved on... Try and test your better mouse-trap. Once you've demonstrated it works, we can talk again. Meanwhile, we have a job to do: liberating the peer-reviewed literature, such as it is, now: http://www.eprints.org -------------------------------------------------------------------- Stevan Harnad [email protected] Professor of Cognitive Science [email protected] Department of Electronics and phone: +44 23-80 592-582 Computer Science fax: +44 23-80 592-865 University of Southampton http://www.ecs.soton.ac.uk/~harnad/ Highfield, Southampton http://www.princeton.edu/~harnad/ SO17 1BJ UNITED KINGDOM NOTE: A complete archive of the ongoing discussion of providing free access to the refereed journal literature online is available at the American Scientist September Forum (98 & 99 & 00): http://amsci-forum.amsci.org/archives/American-Scientist-Open-Access-Forum.html You may join the list at the site above. Discussion can be posted to: [email protected]
