I continue to be a bit surprised that this particular issue is discussed on the basis of whether it is "law" or "policy". The question of when and where Dr X went public to "the whole world" on a scientific matter - and I mean scientific in the broadest sense - seems to me to be an intrinsic feature of our present system of scholarly communication. Scholarly communication and the building of scholarly knowledge assumes that someone makes a "public statement of position" of this kind and must then accept that their ideas can be tested in the usual ways which operate in the various disciplines. Scholarly communication also assumes that going public in this way implicitly underpins any future claim to have been the first to state something, in any future dispute about "who got there first". Hence, it has always seemed to me to be essential that we need to be clear whether the deposit of an article in an e-print archive represents "publication", not for legal or policy reasons but because of the nature of scholarship and the way that the corpus of knowledge of any particular discipline is built up, through the efforts of individual scholars over time. At present, we do not seem to be clear - though it looks to me, for all intents and purposes, as though deposit of an article in an e-print repository represents "publication" in the scholarly sense. How would anyone who plagiarised such a deposited article stand if they claimed that the knowledge they had plagiarised "had not been published" and therefore that the intellectual ownership of it had not been established to the world at large in the traditional scholarly way? It may be that, in the world of e-repositories, the whole question of what constitutes "first publication" needs to be re-examined carefully. My guess is that sooner or later there will be a row about it, probably between two ambitious and competitive scholars. It would be better if we were clear on this point before that happens.
If the conclusion is that prior deposit in an e-archive is "publication" in the scholarly sense, I should be rather surprised if publishers don't consider that important. "You first read it in our pages" is one of the things they pride themselves on. Bernard Naylor On Mon, 6 Nov 2000 17:10:50 +0000 (GMT) Stevan Harnad <[email protected]> wrote: > On Fri, 3 Nov 2000, Martin Melaugh wrote: > > > Has any academic expressed a worry about the possible reaction of a journal > > publisher if they are made aware that a 'pre-print' version of an article > > has been made available on the web? A colleague suggested to me that he > > would be anxious about self-archiving if there was any chance of the > > publisher refusing to publish the paper version. > > You are asking about the policy often called the "Ingelfinger Rule" and > practised by some (not all or even most) journals (e.g., The New > England Journal of Medicine, Science, the journals of the American > Psychological Association). > > This topic has been discussed before in this Forum (see the Archives) > and I have written about it in several papers: > > Harnad, S. (2000) E-Knowledge: Freeing the Refereed Journal Corpus > Online. Computer Law & Security Report 16(2) 78-87. [Rebuttal to > Bloom Editorial in Science and Relman Editorial in New England > Journal of Medicine] > http://www.ecs.soton.ac.uk/~harnad/Papers/Harnad/harnad00.scinejm.htm > > Harnad, S. (2000) Ingelfinger Over-Ruled: The Role of the Web in > the Future of Refereed Medical Journal Publishing. Lancet (in press) > http://www.ecs.soton.ac.uk/~harnad/Papers/Harnad/harnad00.lancet.htm > > Suffice it to say that such policies are not legal matters, like > copyright, but mere policies. The policies are unjustified and > unenforceable (editors and referees, all researchers like ourselves, > have no interest in enforcing such policies, and becoming net-sleuths, > trawling for look-alikes for every submitted paper from the day it is > submitted to the day it is accepted, for no reason that serves the > interests of research); moreover, these policies are changing (Nature, > unlike Science, has already dropped the Ingelfinger Rule; there are > indications Science may follow suit.) > > -------------------------------------------------------------------- > Stevan Harnad [email protected] > Professor of Cognitive Science [email protected] > Department of Electronics and phone: +44 23-80 592-582 > Computer Science fax: +44 23-80 592-865 > University of Southampton http://www.ecs.soton.ac.uk/~harnad/ > Highfield, Southampton http://www.princeton.edu/~harnad/ > SO17 1BJ UNITED KINGDOM > > NOTE: A complete archive of the ongoing discussion of providing free > access to the refereed journal literature online is available at the > American Scientist September Forum (98 & 99 & 00): > > > http://amsci-forum.amsci.org/archives/American-Scientist-Open-Access-Forum.html > > You may join the list at the site above. > > Discussion can be posted to: > > [email protected] > > ---------------------- Bernard Naylor Email: [email protected] University Librarian Tel: 023 8059 2677 University of Southampton Fax: 023 8059 5451 Highfield Southampton, SO17 1BJ
