Can I seek information about a topic which might constitute a new thread?
I have been concerned for a little while about how one goes about "authenticating" a document, lets say an eprint. Authenticating means, inter alia, two things a) Is the author authentic, and how can one check this b) Has the article changed since the author last did so? If so, by whom? I saw no mention of these aspects in http://www.eprints.org/software.html but perhaps this topic is discussed, and if it is I would welcome pointers (and apologize for this FAQ). Although a rather different kind of eprint, I now have on my computer some 30 Acrobat PDF files from various publishers which constitutes most of my published opus of the last four years or so. I downloaded them all via site licenses, and also as their author. I presume my holding them is not inappropriate! Curiously, none of these 30 Acrobat files seem to have much in the way of any authentication mechanism. In this case, it would be "did this publisher really issue this Acrobat file, and has it been changed since they did so?" (I presume to trust the publisher to authenticate the author(s) ). What I was expecting was perhaps a digital signature, which Acrobat distiller can easily insert into the whole document (based on so called X.509 certificates), but found none in the random selection of the 30 articles I looked in. Acrobat also has mechanisms to lock the article to prevent it from being modified. These mechanisms too did not seem to be used by any of my publishers. Which I found quite surprising, maybe even distressing. Dealing specifically with the eprint software, I note that most any type of document could be accepted as an eprint format. Some might be more suitable for authentication than others! I also note from the eprint site that "4.2.2 Validation /opt/eprints/site_lib/Validate.pm contains routines which are called by the core code to ensure that uploaded information is valid." I wonder what that could constitute? Does valid mean authenticity checks for X.509 certificates for example, as provided by the author submitting the document? I presume valid does not mean valid in the SGML sense? Although that too would be a jolly good idea. I concluded that "authenticity" is a rather neglected area. Any comments? -- Henry Rzepa. +44 (0)20 7594 5774 (Office) +44 (0)20 7594 5804 (Fax) Dept. Chemistry, Imperial College, London, SW7 2AY, UK. http://www.ch.ic.ac.uk/rzepa/
