Steve, I am sure you know perfectly well that there are more choices than

:
>    (i) that preprint quality and usability would stay at its current level if 
> there were no
>               peer review OR
>     (ii) that a hypothetical post-hoc "open 'peer' feedback" (by the
>     readers and users of the Archive) could substitute for the
>     quality-control function currently exerted by peer review.

For example, there are peer-reviewed virtual journals, commercial or
non-commercial, or any one of a number of  arrangements that have  been amd
will be devised.


I also see no reason to doubt that those (includinging of course yourself) who
have devised the current archives sturucture, and the current A&I systems,
will be well up to the challenge of finding ways for

>     navigating, ... systematically evaluating and sign-posting a
>     an unfiltered and unconstrained literature


I  further suggest that what is holding back the wider adoption of these
systems is  not just

> uncertain speculations

but the refusal of proponents of the various schemes to accept the possiblity
that others may have equally good ideas, and that judging by what

>  sounds quite speculative, not to mention subjective, to me...

is not a sufficient criterion.




--
David Goodman
Biology Librarian
and Co-chair, Electronic Journals Task force
Princeton University Library
Princeton, NJ 08544-0001
phone: 609-258-3235
fax: 609-258-2627
e-mail: [email protected]

Reply via email to