On Thu, 28 Nov 2002, Jan Velterop wrote: > The perception that I wanted to steer the discussion in the direction > of peer-review reform is perhaps the reason why Stevan as moderator > chose not to post my full contribution on the September98-list (fair > enough, that's his prerogative) but only the bits to which he reacts
No, it was a mistake on my part! I think you posted it originally only to BOAI, so I didn't re-post it to AmSci, but posted only my quote/comments. I will go back now, and re-post it from the BOAI archives to AmSci. I apologize.. > (I'll post the full contribution to the bmanifesto-list shortly, so > that my open access friends can have a complete record of the > discussion; the hiatuses are minor, but I just don't like censorship of > any kind on discussion lists). Jan, I take full responsibility for the times I invoke cloture, but I always announce it openly. This was not such a case! It was an error. (Did you post the original to AmSci too, or only to BOAI?) > But my topic is not peer-review reform > per se; the issue is and was the impediments that entrenched, > traditional scientometric qualifyers are putting up for new open access > journals. These impediments are presumably alright if one believes that > open access to peer-reviewed literature is only ever realistically > possible if articles published in entrenched, traditional journals are > being mounted on open institutional or self-archives, but I don't, and > I happen to know quite a few people who believe with me that there are > other ways to the proverbial Rome as well, such as journals published > with open access from the outset. It is not my (undenied) preference for the BOAI-1 route (for the reasons I have so often stated) that is responsible for the fact that any new journal, regardless of medium or economic model, faces an uphill battle until it manages to establish a track-record of some kind. "Track-record" simply means reliable and persisting evidence (hence predictor) of quality. This fact about the need for a track-record is not (just) because of a bias for "traditional" journals; nor is it because of the tyranny of the ISI journal-impact factor (though it is certainly time for multivariate scientometric flowers to be added to the orchard); nor is it in any way because of my own support for BOAI-1! The struggle to establish a credible track-record as soon as possible is quite understandable for all new journals. They require that in order to attract and sustain authors, readers, citations, and all the other things a journal needs in order to have high quality and impact. THe BMC journals are meeting this challenge admirably, and the Faculty of 1000 reviews are a valuable factor in this. But please, if BMC is still facing challenges, please don't attribute them to my own efforts to promote a parallel path to open access (and one that may eventually make things easier for open-access journals too, if it succeeds). >jv> Of course one can subsequently quantify such qualitative >jv> information. But what a known and acknowledged authority thinks >jv> of an article is to many more interesting than what anonymous >jv> peer-reviewers think. Any research assessment exercise should >jv> seriously look at resources such as offered by Faculty of 1000. > >sh> Let 1000 flowers bloom. But it's rather mis-stating the options to >sh> describe them as open-review vs. anonymous-review! Classical peer >sh> review is one thing. Then there is post-hoc open-review thereafter. > > Your mis-readings; not my mis-statements. Calling F1000 'secondary > review', as I did, is clearly implying that it is complementary, and > not an alternative to conventional journal peer-review. The reason why > any research assessment exercise should look at such secondary > resources is that they offer a) a second opinion by a known reviewer, > and b) an opinion on individual papers rather than average track > records of journals in which those papers were published. I stand corrected. I was misled by the fact that you were advocating nonanonymous primary peer review too (but we agree that that is still just classical peer review, and essential). >jv> "All BMC's medical have open peer review which works most >jv> satisfactorily." Stevan Harnad
