At 11:31 AM 1/17/2003 Friday -0500, Albert Henderson wrote:

        The open access model promises the end of libraries
        and librarians as reductions in library spending
        reach a final conclusion. Such an end to library
        spending will very likely mean an end to journals,
        the economic power of faculty, including learned
        associations, editors, and political leadership.

The open access model will fail if it does not guarantee the continued
support of journals that provide high quality peer review. But there is no
reason why the model cannot accommodate such support.

        More downloads are not necessarily better, since
        the main cost of information is the cost of
        readers' reading and associated activities. Tenopir
        and King point out the cost of readings far exceeds
        the cost of journals and its potential for saving.
        This is where publishers' delivery of select
        material to a select audience outstrips the various
        open plans which force the reader to consider
        unrefereed and quack articles.

Scientists are capable of recognizing reliable sources of information.
Peer-reviewed journals have always served as those sources, and they will
continue to do so in the open access world. Scientists may read unrefereed
preprints from known, reliable colleagues, but they generally do not waste
their time reading unrefereed articles (unless the article was sent to them
for review by the editor of a journal they respect.)

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Lee N. Miller                             phone:  (607) 255-3221
Editor Emeritus
Ecological Society of America
118 Prospect Street, Suite 212
Ithaca, NY  14850  USA            email:  [email protected]

Reply via email to