> Date: Sun, 5 Oct 2003 11:21:45 +0530 > From: Subbiah Arunachalam <[email protected]> > > Dear Stevan: > > Here is a senior scientist from Russia with some reservations about self > archiving and open access. Maybe you would like to convince him. He is a > Fellow of TWAS. Regards. > > Arun
Dear Arun, No doubt because of the long years of relative isolation, this Russian inquiry recapitulates the past 1.5 decade-history of open-access, raising several of the 28 prima facie worries (all groundless) that have been answered repeatedly in this Forum and have even turned into the self-archiving FAQs. http://www.eprints.org/self-faq/ I will reply in summary first and then to each of the 3 questions, also citing the pertinent FAQ. > From: [Identity Deleted] > Sent: Friday, October 03, 2003 3:38 PM > Subject: Re: TWAS, WSIS and open access > > Dear Subbiah Arunachalam, > > I agree with your estimation of situation concerning problems with > access to journals and ICT. We have a same situation in Russia. Now > Russia become close to Third World countries. > > I suppose that creating open access archives and journals undermine > business of publishing companies. And we can expect large resistance. > I see some problems. There is certainly some resistance to open access among peer-reviewed journal publishers, with some publishers worrying that it may undermine their business. However, what is best for publishers' current cost-recovery methods and modera operandi must be weighed against what is best for research and researchers. Open access is so clearly the optimal and inevitable solution for research and researchers that no publisher can explicitly oppose open access per se. That would be tantamount to declaring that publishers were opposed to what was best for research and researchers. And that position would only be tenable if access-toll-based cost-recovery were somehow a necessary condition for publishing peer-reviewed research at all. But that is clearly no longer the case in the online age. Most journal publishers accordingly support open access. 500 (out of the total of the world's 24,000 peer-reviewed journals) do so by being or becoming open-access journals: http://www.doaj.org/ Of the remaining journals, 55% of the Romeo Project's sample of the top 7135 are already "green," i.e., already explicitly support open access by supporting the author self-archiving of either preprints or postprints or both. http://www.lboro.ac.uk/departments/ls/disresearch/romeo/Romeo%20Publisher%20Policies.htm Most of the remaining Romeo "white" journals will agree to self-archiving if asked. And for the few who do not agree, there is still a legal solution that allows all authors to self-archive: http://www.eprints.org/self-faq/#copyright1 Moreover, in the fields that have been self-archiving the most and the longest -- physics and mathematics -- there has not been a single publisher request to remove any of the 200,000+ articles that have been self-archived to date (since the inception of the Physics Arxiv, arxiv.org, in 1991). The changes induced by self-archiving are gradual enough and distributed enough so that no one knows whether and when they will ever affect journal revenue streams. If and when they do, there are ways that journals can adapt (cost-cutting to eliminate products and services that become obsolete, such as the paper product, and eventually even online text-provision, offloading archiving and access onto the distributed system of OAI-compliant and interoperable institutional archives themselves). The 500 brave new open-access journals have pre-adapted already. The open-access journal's costs are paid at the author/institution end instead of the reader/institution end. The open-access journal may eventually downsize to becoming purely a peer-review service-provider and certifier rather than the provider of a text-product, whether on-paper or on-line. http://www.nature.com/nature/debates/e-access/Articles/harnad.html#B1 http://www.ecs.soton.ac.uk/~harnad/Hypermail/Amsci/0303.html > 1. Building of communism for scientists in capitalist world demands a > lot of money. Who will pay? The communist practice in our country is > show that people's work must be paid. If people don't get normal > salary they work very bad. I don't belive in volunteers or enthusiasts > work. Relevant self-faq: http://www.eprints.org/self-faq/#14.Capitalism As noted above, the essential costs of publication can be paid on either the reader/institution end or the author-institution end, so open-access does not rely on philanthropy or communism! But what *are* the essential products and services of a peer-reviewed journal in the online age? Authors provide the text, and do the revisions in response to peer review. The peer-reviewers referee -- and have always refereed -- for free. The network of OAI-compliant Institutional Eprint Archives can provide the access. So it is likely that the true costs of online-age peer-reviewed journal publication will be much lower, if and when they are reduced to the essentials by market pressure. For now, however, the toll-access journals can compete with the existing open-access journals, and can co-exist with the open-access versions of those of their articles that are self-archived by their authors (as physics journals have been doing since 1991). > There are two operational systems Linux and Windows. Linux and > soft for Linux are free of charge, but very bad. It's example of > communism in computer's world. We need many sponsors for maintaining > of work. I have no comment on the Windows/Linux comparison (though I think Linux is very good!). Peer-reviewed research, unlike software, is and always has been an author give-away, written solely for research impact, not for royalty revenue. "On the Deep Disanalogy Between Text and Software... http://www.ecs.soton.ac.uk/~harnad/Hypermail/Amsci/2967.html > 2. I suppose we have a danger to create bad system. There are a lot of > scientific "noise". Some journals can be named as basket for garbage. > We can build up a new huge basket. Relevant self-faq: http://www.eprints.org/self-faq/#7.Peer The open-access movement is targeting the peer-reviewed journal literature. The objective is to free this literature from access-tolls, not from peer review. > 3. The serious scientists will publish results in main journals. In > Russia we haven't money to pay journals for publishing papers. Relevant self-faq: http://www.eprints.org/self-faq/#8.Paying There are two roads to open access: open-access publication (BOAI-2) and open-access self-archiving (BOAI-1). For the 95% of articles that either have no suitable open-access journal or the author/institution cannot afford the open-access journal's publication fee, there is always the option of self-archiving. Open access is not identical with open access publication: http://www.soros.org/openaccess/read.shtml "On the Need to Take Both Roads to Open Access" http://www.ecs.soton.ac.uk/~harnad/Hypermail/Amsci/2995.html > This journals are unreachable for most of Russian scientists. Western > countries built the new Berlin's wall. They create the conditions for > brain leakage. The most talented scientists must work abroad for low > salary if compare with native scientists. This situation is very > profit for government of Western countries. They get ready scientists > and used them in more productive part of life. It means that we can > have resistance from Western governments. Open access is one of the ways of plugging the brain-drain, helping to equalize both the access-differential and the impact differential between the richer and poorer countries. "Access-Denial, Impact-Denial and the Developing and Developed World" http://www.ecs.soton.ac.uk/~harnad/Hypermail/Amsci/2171.html Stevan Harnad NOTE: A complete archive of the ongoing discussion of providing open access to the peer-reviewed research literature online is available at the American Scientist September Forum (98 & 99 & 00 & 01 & 02 & 03): http://amsci-forum.amsci.org/archives/American-Scientist-Open-Access-Forum.html or http://www.ecs.soton.ac.uk/~harnad/Hypermail/Amsci/index.html Discussion can be posted to: [email protected]
