Hi Arthur, I am glad that you did not intend what came across as a slight to those engaging in grass-roots advocacy where their institutions are still relying on the voluntarist approach and have not yet achieved a mandate. As I have said, even though I don't dispute that voluntarism fails to fill repositories, it does form an important part of the initial development of a repository - and it is important for yourselves as advocates nearer to the political end of OA, with established repositories youselves, to cast your minds back to how things used to be when you were in this situation: the majority of repositories are not yet so well established, as you know.
I take this approach because the case studies and content that have already arisen from my engagement with academics volunteering to archive their work form a major part of the resources that I can use to convince the departments and management to support a mandate, as well as to raise awareness amongst other academics before the event, essentially to get them on side whether or not they are in practice too fundamentally lazy to actually archive their papers without a prior mandate in place. I am not, as you put it, fooling myself into thinking that I can get compliance through voluntarism, but this is where we must start. I have absolutely no choice in this matter, of course. I must lay the groundwork on which a future mandate can work. Without such groundwork, as I maintain, no mandate would be able to work in practice. In essence, we need the first 15-20% before the rest is within our reach. Thank you for the useful information about the Patchwork Mandate, which I will look at with great interest. Another reason why it might be that student theses are mandated sooner than staff research (apart from the general fear of the employer about possible trade union action based on copyright issues relating to academic research) is highlighted by the experience of the average cataloguing librarian: the paper copies are expensive and time-consuming to process, so it is an obvious cost advantage to both students and libraries to work towards dispensing with them. With regard to your last point, that you seek to promote realism rather than discourage repository managers on this list, this is very welcome indeed to hear. I am very grateful for the information, as I have no doubt other repository managers are too. If you bear in mind the needs of those managing embryonic repositories, please consider more often the path as well as the goal, then perhaps no more of these unnecessary disagreements will arise between us. With best wishes, Talat
