On Sat, 9 Feb 2008, Thomas Krichel wrote: > > Stevan Harnad: > > Yes, the three first ranks go to "thematic" (i.e., discipline- or > > subject-based) Central Repositories (CRs): (1) Arxiv (Physics), (2) > > Repec > > (Economics) and (3) E-Lis (Library Science). That is to be expected, > > because such CRs are fed from institutions all over the world. > > Thomas Krichel: > Yeah, but E-LIS is really small, looking at it today it tells > us it has 7253 documents. That IRs struggle to compete with that > sort of effort demonstrates that IRs don't populate, even in the > presence of mandates. No amount of Driver summits will change this. > > Disclaimer: I am the founder of RePEc and also do volunteer work > for E-LIS.
(0) IRs "don't populate, even in the presence of mandates"? (Could Tom please state his evidence for this, comparing the 12 mandated IRs so far with unmandated control IRs -- as Arthur Sale did for a subset, demonstrating the exact opposite of what Tom here claims.) http://fcms.its.utas.edu.au/scieng/comp/project.asp?lProjectId=1830 (Perhaps all Tom means here is that ROARMAP is not yet populated with enough mandates -- in which case I suggest he stay tuned, and watch what happens in 2008.) (1) I don't know the Webometrics ranking formula, but it is clearly based on multiple weighted parameters, and not merely on total number of records (country, size, visibility, rich files, "scholar"), otherwise the rank order would have been the same as what ROAR gives you if you select "Sort by Total Records": http://roar.eprints.org/?action=home&q=&country=&version=&type=&order=record count&submit=Filter The Webometrics "Size" parameter seems to be the same as ROAR's "Total records" -- except Webometrics so far seems to omit PubMedCentral, which would otherwise be the biggest of the CRs. I expect that Webometrics' coverage and perhaps also their formula is still being refined. [They only seem to cover a total of 200 CRs and IRs right now.] And of course there is also still the not-yet-solved problem of distinguishing the records that are full-texts from those that are just metadata, and distinguishing OA content from other kinds of deposits. Stay tuned. http://trac.eprints.org/projects/iar/wiki/Missing Another prominent omission is OAIster, which of course is a harvested meta-repository of repositories (both IRs and CRs) -- but that should cause some logical reflection about the notion of a "CR" altogether: For of course OAIster is itself a CR! Moreover, some of the other CRs are themselves harvested, either from individual websites or from IRs. (CiteSeer is, and so is Repec -- and so, for that matter, are Google Scholar and Google!) So the CR-enthusiasts still need to sort out their logic: they must sort out harvested CRs from CRs that are deposited into directly. (My own provisional conclusion is that as it becomes obvious that virtually every researcher has or will shortly have his own institution's IR, it is the local OAI-compliant IRs (including departmental IRs) that are the natural, optimal, and systematic locus of direct deposit, since institutions are the direct providers of the research in any case. "CRs" should be seen and treated as central services, harvesting (either full-texts or just their metadata) from the distributed IRs, rather than being seen as alternative "repositories", either for direct deposit (in foolish and dysfunctional competition with direct IR deposit), or as entrants in a size competition with IRs -- when the institutions and their IRs are the source of their contents in any case!) (And CRs are encouraged and welcome to enhance the metadata of their harvested contents. But metadata enhancement should not get in the way of content provision itself: That is putting the cart before the (still largely absent) horse!) (2) All repositories are still "struggling" for content. Arxiv and Repec are based on long-standing, semi-successful spontaneous self-archiving practices by a very small, unchanging number of disciplines (and even that is very far from covering all or most of the research article output of Physics or Economics). The rest of Physics and Economics -- and the rest of the disciplines, and the rest of the research institutions of the world -- are not capturing their research output spontaneously. That is by now quite obvious. The solution is equally obvious, tried, tested, and already shown to successfully approach a deposit rate of 100% within 1-2 years: Green Self-Archiving Mandates. http://www.eprints.org/openaccess/policysignup/ But again, comparing IRs and CRs in this regard is comparing apples and fruit: There are (growing alongside (i) the one high-volume spontaneous self-archiving CR, Arxiv, (ii) the semi-central CR, Repec, and (iii) the harvested CR, Citeseer), 12 university mandates and 22 funder mandates adopted, several quite recently -- plus 9 more proposed, including nation-wide multi-university mandate proposals in Brazil, and across the 791 universities in 46 countries in Europe. And the question of the *locus* of mandated deposit still needs to be sorted out for the funder mandates: they ought to be mandating IR deposit and central harvesting rather than going against the tide by needlessly mandating direct central deposit. http://openaccess.eprints.org/index.php?/archives/136-guid.html So it's early days for IR mandates, hence also for IR content over and above the spontaneous deposit baseline of about 15%. But stay tuned to see whether it is the apples, oranges, etc. or the fruit that prove to multiply more fruitfully! http://roar.eprints.org/index.php?action=generate_chart&chart_type=stacked (3) Disclaimer: I started in 1994 as an institutional self-archiving advocate. But then, foolishly enthralled by the spontaneous success of Arxiv, I temporarily switched allegiance to central self-archiving. But with the creation of the OAI harvesting protocol in 1999, which effectively made IRs and CRs all interoperable, hence equivalent, my allegiance sensibly reverted to where it should have stayed all along: to the systematic source of all the target content, namely, each researcher's own institutional IR. The institutions are the direct providers of all the OA target content. It is in their own interests and within their means to ensure that it is all made OA in their own IRs. That is the optimal solution that scales, naturally and systematically, to cover all of the world's research output, across all disciplines, institutions, languages and nations. The rest is just a matter of central harvesting, indexing, data-mining, and metadata enrichment of the IR contents. But the first and foremost objective is OA content provision, now; and the natural host for that is the author's own local IR. http://openaccess.eprints.org/index.php?/archives/344-guid.html (It was my impression that Tom Krichel too was a fan of distributed local self-archiving and central harvesting; as I recall, he was one of those who warned me off of centralism during my brief fatuous flirtation with it. But now Tom seems so comfortable with the continuing spontaneous deposit rate of economists that he does not notice that this spontaneous formula has utterly failed to generalize to all other disciplines for well over a decade now, and that Green OA IR Self-Archiving Mandates have meanwhile become the tried, tested and proven means of generating 100% locally. Hence it is toward generalizing those mandates that the OA movement must now devote its efforts (and is indeed doing so, successfully). Stevan Harnad AMERICAN SCIENTIST OPEN ACCESS FORUM: http://amsci-forum.amsci.org/archives/American-Scientist-Open-Access-Forum.h tml http://www.ecs.soton.ac.uk/~harnad/Hypermail/Amsci/ UNIVERSITIES and RESEARCH FUNDERS: If you have adopted or plan to adopt a policy of providing Open Access to your own research article output, please describe your policy at: http://www.eprints.org/signup/sign.php http://openaccess.eprints.org/index.php?/archives/71-guid.html http://openaccess.eprints.org/index.php?/archives/136-guid.html OPEN-ACCESS-PROVISION POLICY: BOAI-1 ("Green"): Publish your article in a suitable toll-access journal http://romeo.eprints.org/ OR BOAI-2 ("Gold"): Publish your article in an open-access journal if/when a suitable one exists. http://www.doaj.org/ AND in BOTH cases self-archive a supplementary version of your article in your own institutional repository. http://www.eprints.org/self-faq/ http://archives.eprints.org/ http://openaccess.eprints.org/
