I can't help thinking that only looking for positive evidence is not very scientific.
Earlier this year I conducted a survey of members of UK learned societies in the biological sciences. I had 1368 valid responses, and less than half of those respondents knew what self-archiving was; 36% thought it was a good idea and 50% were unsure. Just under half said they used repositories of self-archived articles, but 13% of the sources they named were not in fact self-archiving repositories. 29% said they self-archived their own articles, but once again 10% of the sites where they said they did so were not in fact publicly accessible sites of any kind. The access and convenience of self-archiving repositories were seen as positive, but there were concerns about quality control, workload for authors and institutions, chaotic proliferation of versions, and potential damage to existing journals, publishers and societies. Interestingly, although there was still a significant level of misunderstanding, the respondents were much more positive about OA publication - most of them said they supported the idea of OA journals. 60% said that they read OA journals and 25% that they published in them, but in both cases around 1/3 of the journals named were not OA. While many were in favour of increased access through OA journals, concerns were expressed about the cost to authors, possible reduction in quality, and negative impact on existing journals, publishers and societies. I hope to publish an article on the findings early next year. Sally PS I really don't want to hear why anyone on this list thinks the respondents were wrong - I'm just reporting facts! Sally Morris Consultant, Morris Associates (Publishing Consultancy) South House, The Street Clapham, Worthing, West Sussex BN13 3UU, UK Tel: +44(0)1903 871286 Fax: +44(0)8701 202806 Email: [email protected] ____________________________________________________________________________ From: American Scientist Open Access Forum [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Stevan Harnad Sent: 03 November 2008 11:42 To: [email protected] Subject: Alma Swan on "Reasons researchers really rate repositories" Les Carr has posted a call: Looking for Evidence of Researcher Engagement with Repositories "a collection of success stories - anecdotes of how repositories have been able to improve the lot of researchers - for appealing to institutional repository nay-sayers and open access agnostics" and the redoubtable Alma Swan has, as always, responded with data, posting: Reasons researchers really rate repositories
