I have little doubt that it is raised in earnest because I have heard similar comments; some academics enjoy some income from copying of their articles and therefore have concerns that their income will drop with OA. In my view, they really don't get the point of OA, or indeed of why they are publishing in the first place. Charles
Professor Charles Oppenheim Head Department of Information Science Loughborough University Loughborough Leics LE11 3TU Tel 01509-223065 Fax 01509 223053 e mail [email protected] ____________________________________________________________________________ From: American Scientist Open Access Forum [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Stevan Harnad Sent: 24 November 2008 14:06 To: [email protected] Subject: Royalty-Seeking on Impact-Seeking Give-Away Content? ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From: Sheppard, Nick <N.E.Sheppard -- leedsmet.ac.uk> List-Post: [email protected] List-Post: [email protected] Date: Mon, Nov 24, 2008 at 7:10 AM Subject: ACLS and royalties To: JISC-REPOSITORIES -- jiscmail.ac.uk An academic has recently contacted me with an enquiry about ACLS [Authors' Licensing and Collecting Service ] and the payment of royalties on material downloaded from IRs: > The other aspect of this is that academics - under the ACLS > service - authors collecting and licencing service - derive > (admittedly small) amounts of money from institutional copying > charges world wide of >published articles. If we start putting up > essays on a repository, we are in danger of cutting off a > legitimate source of income for our work - some years it might > be 70 quid others it might be 220 from p/copying in Norway > and USA or Europe etc. If the ACLS were able to figure the > number of hits to university repositories, we could continue > to receive payment on the basis of our copyright ownership. I spoke to someone at ACLS who told me they are unsure of where they stand on the issue themselves and referred me to the Society of Authors for further advice. Thought I'd try the list first... It is hard to discern whether this question was raised in earnest or in jest! Does anyone imagine that the authors of refereed journal articles would gain more from (1) the pennies they might demand from ALCS tolls on viewing their content (online viewing tolls alongside the subscription tolls from which OA was meant to free refereed research articles) than they would from (2) the enhanced uptake, usage, and impact that OA itself provides, freeing their published papers from all user-access-toll barriers -- and (3) the contribution of that enhanced impact to their performance evaluations, salaries, promotions, RAE ranking and research funding? OA is about author-giveaway content: refereed journal articles, written only for research usage and impact. OA is not about royalty-seeking books, nor fee-based magazine articles. How on earth does ALCS get into this at all? 1.1. Distinguish the non-give-away literature from the give-away literature 1.2. Distinguish income (arising from article sales) from impact (arising from article use) http://cogprints.org/1639/1/resolution.htm#1.1 Stevan Harnad
