On 2013-07-18, at 7:39 AM, Marianne Haska <[email protected]> 
wrote:

> Replies below from a much objective Graham Triggs to Stephen Harnad

I've already replied to the much more objective Graham Triggs: 
http://j.mp/RepTriggs

But can representatives of the Royal Society not speak for themselves? 

And I'm not referring to the RS's hybrid Gold option -- which is not, as I 
said, the 
relevant criterion for deciding whether the RS is being "fair" -- but to the 
RS's fall 
from its prior (2010) policy of endorsing immediate, unembargoed Green OA 
self-archiving by its authors:

Not a Proud Day in the Annals of the Royal Society (24 November 2005)


Royal Society Endorses Immediate Green OA Self-Archiving By Its Authors (22 
June 2010)

Stevan Harnad

>  
> 
> On Tuesday, 16 July 2013 03:07:58 UTC+2, Stevan Harnad wrote:
> On Mon, Jul 15, 2013 at 7:02 PM, LIBLICENSE <[email protected]> wrote
>  
> "Remaining a fair player, The Royal Society ensures that published open 
> access articles bearing a publication fee are deducted from subscription 
> prices through its Transparent Pricing Mechanism"
> http://royalsocietypublishing.org/site/librarians/transparent_pricing.xhtml";
> 
> The Royal Society thereby pledges that it will not "double-dip" for hybrid 
> Gold OA. The RS continues to collect subscription fees from institutions 
> worldwide, but whatever additional revenue if gets from individual authors 
> for hybrid Gold OA, it pledges to return as a subscription rebate to all 
> subscribing institutions. 
> 
> But does this mean the RS is a "fair player" insofar as OA is concerned?
> 
> Hardly. 
>  
> Actually, whilst there is an increase in the number of non-OA articles, this 
> is more than fair (assuming that the current subscription rate is fair, and 
> their costs are in line with inflation). It's not quite so fair in the case 
> that the number of non-OA publications is decreasing.
> 
>  
> Yet this is not because the hybrid Gold OA rebate amounts to individual 
> authors' full payments for Gold OA subsidizing the subscription costs of 
> institutions worldwide. (The author's own institution only gets back a tiny 
> fraction of its authors' Gold OA fee in its tiny portion of the worldwide 
> subscription rebate.)
> 
> No. Whether the RS is indeed a fair player depends on whether RS authors have 
> the choice -- between providing Gold OA by paying the RS that additional cost 
> over and above what the world's institutions are already paying the RS in 
> subscriptions -- or providing Green OA at no additional cost, by 
> self-archiving their article free for all online.
> 
> There are no rebates due for Gold OA publishing. It is not subsidizing the 
> subscription costs worldwide. Author-paid content, and subscription-paid 
> content are separate things, and the revenue is (in this case) being counted 
> separately. You (or rather, your funder gives you extra to) pay for what you 
> want to make open. And you pay for what isn't open if you want to read it.
> 
>  
> Very simply - if, instead of publishing with the Royal Society, you published 
> your open article (and paid the APC) in PLoS, would you expect a rebate on 
> your Royal Society subscription, which would still be covering *exactly* the 
> same amount of closed access content?
> 
> 
> But now -- perhaps -- the RS seems to have adopted a 12-month embargo on 
> Green OA (under the fell influence -- perhaps -- of the new Finch/RCUK OA 
> policy?):
> 
> "You are free to post…the “Author Generated Postprint” - Your personal copy 
> of the revised version of the Article as accepted by Us… on Your personal or 
> institutional web site and load it onto an institutional or not for profit 
> repository no earlier than 12 months from the date of first publication of 
> the Definitive Published Version." 
> http://royalsocietypublishing.org/site/authors/licence.xhtml
> 
> Or is this just another (silly) attempt to distinguish between authors 
> positing on their "institutional website" (unembargoed) versus posting in 
> their "institutional repository" (embargoed) -- in which case RS authors can 
> happily ignore this empty pseudo-distinction, knowing that their 
> institutional repository is indeed their institutional website.
> 
> No, according to that resource they have exactly the same policy that covers 
> loading / depositing the postprint to any online resource - personal website, 
> institutional website ore repository. The only distinction they make is that 
> you can use the postprint internally, or email to colleagues without embargo. 
> All online / systematic distribution is limited by the embargo period.
> 

_______________________________________________
GOAL mailing list
[email protected]
http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal

Reply via email to