On Sun, Oct 6, 2013 at 9:10 AM, Paul Colin de Gloucester < [email protected]> wrote:
*SH:* The natural way to charge for the service of peer review then will be > on a "no-fault basis," with the author's institution or funder paying for > each round of refereeing, *regardless of outcome (acceptance, > revision/re-refereeing, or rejection)*. This will minimize cost > while protecting against inflated acceptance rates and decline in > quality standards." > > *CPG:* The cost of refereeing would be more than nothing, and many > journals do not pay referees. > I didn't say it would be nothing; I said it would be minimal (compared to subscription revenues, per article: $1000-5000+). I also did not say referees would be or should be paid: it is the management of the refereeing process (picking referees and adjudicating referee reports and revisions) that I estimated would cost about $200 per round of no-fault refereeing. Many thanks for the references to the non-OA stings, below. Stevan Harnad > More stings of refereeing of non-open-access journals: > > Seidl, C., & Schmidt, U., & Grösche, P. (2005). The performance of peer > review and a beauty contest of referee processes of economics journals. > Estudios de Economía Aplicada, 23(3): 505-551, > HTTP://DialNet.UniRioja.Es/**descarga/articulo/1394347.pdf<HTTP://DialNet.UniRioja.Es/descarga/articulo/1394347.pdf> > > de Gloucester, P. C. (2013). Referees Often Miss Obvious Errors in > Computer and Electronic Publications. Accountability in Research: > Policies and Quality Assurance, 20(3), 143-166. > > Also see: > > Labbé, C., & Labbé, D. (2013). Duplicate and fake publications in the > scientific literature: How many SCIgen papers in computer science? > Scientometrics, 94(1): 379-396. > > Newton, D. P. (2010). Quality and Peer Review of Research: An > Adjudicating Role for Editors. Accountability in Research: Policies > and Quality Assurance, 17(3), 130-145, this is available as open > access: > WWW.TandFonline.com/doi/full/**10.1080/08989621003791945#**tabModule<http://WWW.TandFonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/08989621003791945#tabModule> > > Regards, > Paul Colin de Gloucester
_______________________________________________ GOAL mailing list [email protected] http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal
