Christian, and other readers of this list,

It seems to me that many researchers are unhappy with any kind of requirement or imposition, resorting to the 'academic freedom' argument rather (all too?) quickly and easily. But librarians are in a bind. They can't really cancel most subscriptions or BigDeal licences without invoking the ire of faculty, which makes it impossible for them to have meaningful negotiations with publishers, because there is no way for them to have a 'walk-away point', so important when negotiating. Publishers know, of course, that librarians are not in a position to negotiate, and even if negotiations are escalated up to the level of university leaders, such as we found in The Netherlands recently, their position is also fairly weak as they face pressure from both the publishers and their faculty, not to risk reducing access to subscription journals. Complaining is cheap for faculty: they don't pay for subscriptions and often are not even fully aware of the cost.

My proposal to make members of the faculty pay for articles they publish in subscription journals was meant to address this lack of awareness. If charging them for publishing in subscription journals doesn't work — and I recognise the difficult position librarians are in regarding such charges — then at least it shouldn't be beyond the possibility of librarians to do more to make authors aware of the cost of their decision to publish in subscription journals, short of actually charging them. Making them aware of the cost may perhaps not immediately result in changed behaviour, but it could be a very useful nudge in the somewhat longer run (after decades of advocating open access, who notices a year or two?). Does it ever happen? I'd be most interested to hear about instances where it does.

I don't know why you think that cancelling subscriptions and getting rid of BigDeal licences would not upset researchers much. I am very skeptical of that idea. However, if you would cancel and replace all subscriptions by a 'pay-by-the-drink' approach, whereby individual articles are bought upon request, from any journal, you may be on to something. You would ensure access for researchers (and potentially to a much wider range of journals than you can possibly subscribe to). You would simply be substituting the 'just-in-case' model by an actual usage-based one.

There are no-doubt risks involved, such as researchers 'buying' far more articles than the budget would allow for, and inconveniences, such as needing a transaction for every article, and there will no-doubt be objections from faculty, too, but if done transparently, it would make them more aware of the costs and the anachronisms of the pay-wall system of scholarly publishing.

I am certain that people will protest at this and other proposals as 'bad', 'not workable' et cetera, but the fact is that if other, new, ways of dealing with scholarly literature are not experimented with, nothing will change, and even where it does change, it does so painfully slowly. The idea of open access has been around for decades now, and yet the proportion of articles being available and re-usable barrier-free is still very small, and though growing in number, hardly growing in proportion to everything that is being published (it is my impression that the growth in the total number of articles published is hardly smaller than the number of open access articles every year).

To believe that change will come from publishers is most unrealistic. They have a fiduciary responsibility to shareholders, and not to academia, which militates against the sort of change the scholarly community needs. And even where some changes do occur on the part of publishers — hybrid journals, for instance — they are almost universally denigrated (I'm not saying that is wrong, but it's always done on the basis of 'double-dipping', which is a red herring and masking the real reasons why hybrid journals are an unwelcome development). The optimism with which I, and other members of the original BOAI group of participants insofar as I know, embarked on advocating open access has, at least in my view, mainly been frustrated by deeply held conservatism in academic circles. Most of what I hear and read about open access discussions, is complaints about publishers. All too rarely do I hear or read proposed — or better still, implemented — attempts at solutions. There are very few around. Stevan keeps banging on about self-archiving mandates. Admirable tenacity; poor results, so far. And there are a few new style journal initiatives, such as PeerJ and ScienceOpen and the like, which don't, unfortunately, account for many articles yet, and the so far rather more successful PLOS-One. And that's it. Altogether very small fry in the scheme of things. In fact, 'hybrid' seems to be able to claim the most success. Quite possibly because it preserves most of the old order, including the unnecessarily high cost of the system (doesn't academia just lurve throwing money away?) and the journal pecking order.

Happy New Year! I am still hoping for real changes. Probably being naive.

Jan Velterop
PS. I would agree with 'flipping' now, to get open access, and then sort out cost reduction. I don't see it happening in a hurry, unfortunately.


On 04/01/2016 00:15, Christian Gutknecht wrote:
Stevan,

I guess the record in RoarMap about the policy of the University of Zurich is not correct at that point. The deposition of at least the metadata of a publication in the IR is required to get included in the annual report, which is the foundation of research evaluation. It’s however correct that the distinction of of the accessibility on ZORA (Fulltext freely available or not) is not part of the research evaluation. But I do not know any university that only counts publications that are freely available at the repository.

Also counting records where the full text is restricted but only available with a request-a-copy button as Almost-OA on the same level as OA is not valid for me. With „Request a copy“ there’s always a certain chance that you never will get the full text. Especially for older records you cannot expect the author to answer your request, because he/she may already have left the university.

Regarding the suggested approach of Jan to charge authors publishing in subscription journals, I think this would be a bad option. Any requirement that tells authors where to publish (even indirectly by imposing charges) will be rejected as a not tolerable influence of the academic freedom. I mean some academics already protesting with this argument, if the university requires them to make their full text available on the IR.

But I really like the idea to let researchers feel that subscription is an outdated model. And an easy way to do that without upsetting them too much, is to cancel subscriptions and get rid of the Big Deals. With the free money the library then can create two kind of funds: One is the Gold OA fund (incl. hybrid options but with a cap) and one is the fund for costs resulting getting access to documents that are not longer available via subscription (like costs for pay-per-view, document delivery, individual subscription of a really important journal). I think most libraries would find out that researchers would get along quite well with this option. Because librarians constantly overestimate the importance of their subscriptions and especially the Big Deals where they buy/rent a lot of stuff that is never used by their community. As Thomas mentioned it’s really easy these days to get to the papers by simply asking the author. Also Researchgate and academia.edu <http://academia.edu> close the gap where IRs fail to provide access.

The advantage in this approach is that libraries clearly set the incentive to Gold OA without the need of additional budget. It doesn’t say, don’t publish in subscription journals, it’s just says that subscription is something that isn't supported by default anymore. And changing the default really can make the difference, as there will immediate (Hybrid) Gold OA.

To be honest, I rather have a flip RIGHT NOW with the existing "grotesquely inflated total expenditure“, then going on like this for years where we spend the money anyway to the Closed Access publishers and get nothing in return. It’s not that I’m not concerned about the costs in the Gold OA world. But the current situation is with the subscription business is already so bad, it can’t get worse.

Best regards

Christian

PS: Okay, it can get worse: Paying for Hybrid Gold and keeping the subscriptions like it’s currently done in UK is really not sustainable. But that was clear from the beginning. Maybe it becomes better when offsetting agreements are set in place.



Am 03.01.2016 um 18:31 schrieb Stevan Harnad <[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>>:

Penalizing an institution's /authors/ for publishing their own articles in subscription journals will not help that institution's /users/ gain access to the subscription journal articles of authors /from all other institutions/, hence it will not reduce the institution's subscription budget, just increase the total institutional spend by the author spend. (Hence Jan's is yet another unstable, unscalable solution, the only stable, coherent one being for all authors, at all institutions, to be mandated to provide Green OA <http://blogs.lse.ac.uk/impactofsocialsciences/2014/04/28/inflated-subscriptions-unsustainable-harnad/>.)

To assess the effectiveness of the University of Zürich <http://roarmap.eprints.org/329/> Green OA mandate (which has only one of the two conditions <http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/370203/> for the most effective mandates <http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/375854/>: immediate deposit is required, but deposit is not a precondition for research evaluation) what needs to be counted is not the annual proportion of OA deposits but the annual proportion of immediate-deposits -- because Zora <https://www.zora.uzh.ch/> implements the automated Request-a-Copy Button <http://www.zora.uzh.ch/117835/> to provide Almost-OA <https://www.google.ca/?gfe_rd=cr&ei=MUCJVraTOuiM8Qf8hrn4Cw&gws_rd=ssl#q=button+%22almost-OA%22> for embargoed deposits.

Once (effective) immediate-deposit mandates are universal (or almost-universal), it will be universal (or almost-universal) Green OA plus Almost-OA that will make journal subscriptions cancellable at last, thereby not only forcing the publisher downsizing, cost-cutting and conversion to Fair-Gold OA <https://www.google.ca/?gfe_rd=cr&ei=MUCJVraTOuiM8Qf8hrn4Cw&gws_rd=ssl#q=harnad+%22fair+gold%22>, but also providing institutions and their authors with the windfall subscription cancelation savings out of which to pay the small remaining fair-gold costs (i.e., just peer review alone) many times over.

A "flip <https://www.google.ca/?gfe_rd=cr&ei=MUCJVraTOuiM8Qf8hrn4Cw&gws_rd=ssl#q=harnad+flip+OA>" to today's Fools-Gold, even if it had been possible (which it is not) would simply have flipped today's grotesquely inflated total expenditure from subscription fees to publication fees (before it all flopped the very next day).

(But I have reconciled myself to merely keep pointing the way to the optimal and inevitable outcome without fretting about how long it will take the research community to do the only sensible thing.)

Your Zen Archivangelist

On Sun, Jan 3, 2016 at 8:27 AM, Velterop <[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>> wrote:

    I have advocated this for a while now (but am not aware of any
    university or library that's taken it up):
    Charge authors of your university who insist on publishing in a
    subscription journal either

      * a nominal amount that is based on an estimate of the average
        per-article revenue of subscription journals/publishers
        (about $5000), or
      * the actual subscription amount paid by the university to a
        publisher, divided by the number of articles by authors from
        the university, published in the journals of that publisher.

    These charges should be collected from the authors' grants, be
    put in an open access fund, and then be used by the
    university/library to support authors willing to publish in
    APC-supported open access journals.

    (For those who really don't like the 'gold' strategy and favour
    the 'green' one above all: you could use the open access fund to
    defray the cost of your open repositories and of all the effort
    needed to ensure that every single paper from your university or
    institution is properly and 'findably' deposited.)

    There will no-doubt be practical difficulties with this, but
    perhaps it can be considered as the seed of an approach?

    Jan Velterop

    On 03/01/2016 12:39, Christian Gutknecht wrote:
    Well, I think Thomas is right. As long libraries do not shift
    money from the subscription side to the Gold OA side, the
    transformation will be very very slow.

    Take the University of Zurich for example. I’ve just disclosed
    for the first time ever what they are paying for Elsevier,
    Springer and Wiley and put that in relation with the
    institutional publication behavior in this blog post:
    http://wisspub.net/2016/01/03/zahlungen-der-universitaet-zuerich/

    The University of Zurich has a strong mandate since 2008 with
    probably one of the best staffed OA team (7 persons) in Europe.
    But regarding publications from 2014, only 23% (242 out of 1062)
    from all articles published articles within journals from
    Elsevier, Wiley and Springer Journals are freely accessible via
    the IR. In 2014 too, the University of Zurich paid 3.4 Mio
    CHF/USD to Elsevier, Springer and Wiley only for Journal
    subscriptions.

    The situation becomes even more absurd, when you learn that in
    2014 there were 176 publications authored by the University of
    Zurich that were published by PLOS (which by the way already is
    the half of what the University of Zurich publishes with
    Wiley!). But there is only little institutional funding for APCs
    explicitly limited to humanities. So all authors who wish
    publish with PLOS have to throw in additional money by their own
    research budget, because the library claims to have no
    additional money for large scale Gold OA funding. Fortunately
    for the sake of OA, Swiss authors are willing to pay with the
    own budget that because the financial situation isn’t that bad.
    But think about the chance and the boost for OA, if the
    University of Zurich would shift all or at least a part of the
    money from the journal subscriptions and create a publisher
    neutral Open Access funds.

    So I think we can and should promote more Green OA and care
    about a better compliance. But if we really want to speed up the
    transition to Gold OA we really should consider to give the
    subscription money a new purpose and use it in a coordinated way
    to force the publishers to change their business model. And as I
    heard this was Berlin 12 about.

    Best regards

    Christian Gutknecht





    Am 31.12.2015 um 19:15 schrieb Stevan Harnad
    <[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>>:


    On Dec 31, 2015, at 10:59 AM, Thomas Krichel
    <[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>> wrote:

     Stevan Harnad writes

    1. Actually, no one really knows why it is taking so long to
    reach the
    optimal and inevitable outcome -- universal OA --

     oh I know. It's because libraries are spending money on
    subscriptions.
     And as long as they do, OA remains evitable.

    That’s about as useful as saying that "I know why there is poverty:
    because the rich are rich and the poor are poor."

    Not only is it not possible to treat “libraries” as if they
    were a monolith
    any more than it is possible to treat “authors” as a monolith,
    but it is completely out of the question for a university library
    to cancel subscriptions while its users have no other means to
    access that content.

    (Please don’t reply that they do cancel what they cannot
    afford: that is
    not relevant. Libraries subscribe to as much content that their
    users need
    as they can afford to subscribe to.)

    The only way to make subscriptions cancellable is to first mandate
    and provide (universal — not just local) Green OA
    
<http://blogs.lse.ac.uk/impactofsocialsciences/2014/04/28/inflated-subscriptions-unsustainable-harnad/>.

    SH

    _______________________________________________
    GOAL mailing list
    [email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>
    http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal



    _______________________________________________
    GOAL mailing list
    [email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>
    http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal

-- /C2 Trinity Gate, Epsom Road
    Guildford, Surrey, GU1 3PW
    United Kingdom
    +44 1483 579525 <tel:%2B44%201483%20579525> (landline)
    +44 7525 026991 <tel:%2B44%207525%20026991> (mobile)

    Noordland 44
    2548 WB Den Haag
    The Netherlands
    +31 707611166 <tel:%2B31%20707611166>/

    _______________________________________________
    GOAL mailing list
    [email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>
    http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal


_______________________________________________
GOAL mailing list
[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>
http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal



_______________________________________________
GOAL mailing list
[email protected]
http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal

--
/C2 Trinity Gate, Epsom Road
Guildford, Surrey, GU1 3PW
United Kingdom
+44 1483 579525 (landline)
+44 7525 026991 (mobile)

Noordland 44
2548 WB Den Haag
The Netherlands
+31 707611166/
_______________________________________________
GOAL mailing list
[email protected]
http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal

Reply via email to