DOAJ has been a valuable service to the open access movement over the years, in 
tracking and linking to a select set of open access journals and providing 
metadata that is helpful for researchers like me and to include DOAJ content in 
library services.

Like any service or initiative, DOAJ has its limitations. Based on recent 
discussions, I gather that there is no interest in discussing the limitations, 
brainstorming potential solutions, or exploring underlying assumptions and 
whether the current approach is optimal. This discussion is at an impasse. DOAJ 
is what it is, and this is within the rights of the people who make DOAJ 
decisions.

To conclude my portion of this discussion, I would like to highlight two 
limitations of DOAJ that to me represent important problems for the future of 
scholarly communication with no current solution:


  1.  As a list of suitable OA journals for authors to publish in, DOAJ 
presents some risk to the author as a journal in DOAJ at the time the author 
decides on a submission venue may be removed from DOAJ at a later date. This 
could be a problem for the author if they wish to prove that they publish OA, 
for example to fulfill an open access mandate, or to establish their 
credibility as an OA author. Taking into account funder and institutional 
requirements for OA, this can have a negative financial (loss of grants) and 
promotional impact on the researcher. One solution is for funders and 
universities to exclusively use green OA policies (as I always recommend). 
Recently, I wrote about 33 SpringerOpen journals (13% of their titles) that 
have ceased publication; 31 of the journals are no longer listed either on 
SpringerOpen or DOAJ. I submit that this is a disservice to authors who 
published in these journals. 
https://sustainingknowledgecommons.org/2019/07/22/springer-open-ceased-now-hybrid-oa-identification-challenges/

  2.  As a list to direct authors to content, DOAJ's exclusions are problematic 
for searchers. DOAJ has rejected one of the top fully open access journals in 
my field (The International Journal of Communication) and several smaller fully 
open access journals that I consider essential content. As a researcher, this 
diminishes the usefulness of DOAJ for me. As a professor, I would hesitate to 
refer students to a list that rejects this content. It is nice to know which 
journals are fully open access, active, and meet the DOAJ criteria, but this is 
not sufficient for research purposes.

best,


Dr. Heather Morrison

Associate Professor, School of Information Studies, University of Ottawa

Professeur Agrégé, École des Sciences de l'Information, Université d'Ottawa

Principal Investigator, Sustaining the Knowledge Commons, a SSHRC Insight 
Project

sustainingknowledgecommons.org

[email protected]

https://uniweb.uottawa.ca/?lang=en#/members/706
_______________________________________________
GOAL mailing list
[email protected]
http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal

Reply via email to