Dear Heather,


First of all, thank you very much for reading and for your interesting comments 
on the new article about monitoring OA article metadata from Knowledge Exchange 
(KE).

We agree that OA metadata from publishers should be available not only to 
consortia but to funders as well as at an institutional level. Ideally, the 
metadata should be delivered in an interoperable format, so that data can be 
stored and transferred from accounting systems to institutional repositories 
and other relevant systems.

As consortia already get metadata at journal level from publishers, KE wanted 
to investigate if this was the case for OA article metadata.

The study shows that publishers are able to and do provide article metadata to 
consortia even though much can be improved.

KE hopes to inspire stakeholders to use the metadata checklist - when asking 
publishers for OA article metadata. The checklist and reporting template are 
free to use. Getting OA metadata can help to get an overview of the costs of OA 
publications.

Whether or not it should be consortia, funders or institutions that are 
responsible for collecting data, we will leave for others to decide. We would, 
however, suggest that monitoring happens in a coordinated way and that 
consortia could play a role in collecting this data.



KE certainly shares your vision of Open Scholarship and new formats of research 
output to be recognized.



Best regards,

Anna Mette Morthorst & Juliane Kant









Dr. Juliane Kant
Scientific Library Services and Information Systems

Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG)
German Research Foundation
Kennedyallee 40
53175 Bonn
Tel. +49 (228) 885-2009
Fax +49 (228) 885-713309
[email protected]
www.dfg.de<http://www.dfg.de>

Von: [email protected] <[email protected]> Im Auftrag von Heather 
Morrison
Gesendet: Mittwoch, 27. November 2019 16:06
An: Global Open Access List (Successor of AmSci) <[email protected]>
Betreff: Re: [GOAL] Knowledge Exchange Publication on Monitoring agreements 
with Open Access elements


Thank you for sharing this document, this is very informative.



A comment on the approach: while good intentions are obvious here and the 
overall goal of full open access is one that we share, the monitoring involved 
(demanding article-level metadata from publishers which in turn requires author 
and funder metadata in effect imposing upstream technical requirements) appears 
to be problematic for several reasons.



Monitoring via publisher offsetting agreements is Inefficient in comparison 
with institutional OA repository and IR: when a researcher receives grant 
funding that is administered through a university or research organization, the 
organization is already tracking the individual researcher and the funding. 
This is necessary for accountability purposes; the primary focus of monitoring 
the use of funding is, and should be, ensuring that funds are spent on doing 
research rather than lining peoples' pockets or subsidizing vacations. 
Institutional OA policy and services do not require an additional layer of 
tracking of individual researchers and their grants. If works are deposited in 
the IR, OA status can be determined locally, and reported consortially or 
nationally if desired.



As a researcher with funding, my institution and funding agency both have 
reporting expectations. A funding agency could simply ask for a report on how 
the researcher has met the OA policy as part of the final report. For some 
researchers, this might inspire post-hoc OA action. Similarly, an institution 
can ask researchers to report on OA policy compliance, just as researchers are 
expected to meet policy requirements for research ethics and accountability.



More important, the impact of technical developments for monitoring seem highly 
likely to lock in what should be considered a publishing model based on print 
(journals and books, optimized for the printing press and postal system) that 
should be regarded as in the process of becoming obsolete.



As an open researcher, very little of my work would be reflected in the 
monitoring system described. Attempting to expand the monitoring system to 
include new formats such as open data and research blogs would multiply the 
inefficiencies of monitoring and likely stifle innovation.



There are compelling public interest arguments for global open access. There 
are a lot of details to figure out in the shift to OA, but let's not lose sight 
of the big picture, the potential for uniting humanity in a common quest for 
knowledge, in the process.



Dr. Heather Morrison

Associate Professor, School of Information Studies, University of Ottawa

Professeur Agrégé, École des Sciences de l'Information, Université d'Ottawa

Principal Investigator, Sustaining the Knowledge Commons, a SSHRC Insight 
Project

sustainingknowledgecommons.org

[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>

https://uniweb.uottawa.ca/?lang=en#/members/706

[On research sabbatical July 1, 2019 - June 30, 2020]

________________________________
From: [email protected]<mailto:[email protected]> 
<[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>> on behalf of Kant, 
Juliane <[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>>
Sent: Tuesday, November 26, 2019 8:55 AM
To: Global Open Access List (Successor of AmSci) 
<[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>>
Subject: [GOAL] Knowledge Exchange Publication on Monitoring agreements with 
Open Access elements

Attention : courriel externe | external email

Dear list,



I'm happy to let you know that Knowledge 
Exchange<http://www.knowledge-exchange.info/> (KE) has published the article 
Monitoring agreements with Open Access elements: why article level metadata is 
important.



If  you are interested in monitoring OA publications and monitoring cost data 
for OA publications at a national or institutional level or by funder this may 
be an interesting article for you to read.



The Knowledge Exchange (KE) Monitoring Open Access (OA) task and finish group 
has undertaken research on agreements with OA elements (e.g. agreements with 
APC discounts, offsetting agreements, read and publish agreements) set between 
consortia from KE countries and major publishers between 2016 and early 2019. 
Following recommendations from KE and ESAC it assessed agreements with OA 
elements to investigate what article-level metadata consortia request from 
publishers and what metadata publishers deliver to consortia.



With Plan S research funders requiring a full transition to OA by 2021, the 
delivery of article-level metadata becomes critical to monitor publishers’ 
compliance with Plan S requirements for transformative arrangements.



The research findings showed that:

  *   Not all consortia agreements requested the article-level metadata as 
recommended by KE and ESAC.
  *   Most importantly, none of the publishers provided all the metadata that 
the consortia requested.
  *   Publishers also did not deliver the same metadata across countries and 
this may be due lack of consistency in their practices.

The research findings can be used as a benchmark to monitor how major 
publishers were performing in KE countries until early 2019 and prior to Plan S 
comes into effect in 2021.

You can read the full article here: 
https://insights.uksg.org/articles/10.1629/uksg.489/ and find out more about 
Knowledge Exchange's work on Monitoring Open Access here: 
http://www.knowledge-exchange.info/event/oa-monitoring



We hope the article will give new insights and facilitate collective action. 
Please help us distributing our work and share it widely through your channels!



With best regards,



Juliane Kant



The Knowledge Exchange<http://www.knowledge-exchange.info/> (KE) partners are 
six key national organizations within Europe tasked with developing 
infrastructure and services to enable the use of digital technologies to 
improve higher education and research: CSC<https://www.csc.fi/> in Finland, 
CNRS<http://www.cnrs.fr/index.php> in France, 
DAFSHE<https://ufm.dk/en/the-ministry/organisation/danish-agency-for-science-and-higher-education>
 in Denmark , DFG<http://www.dfg.de/en/> in Germany, 
Jisc<https://www.jisc.ac.uk/> in the UK and SURF<https://www.surf.nl/en> in the 
Netherlands.



Dr. Juliane Kant
Scientific Library Services and Information Systems

Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG)
German Research Foundation
Kennedyallee 40
53175 Bonn
Tel. +49 (228) 885-2009
Fax +49 (228) 885-713309
[email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>
www.dfg.de<http://www.dfg.de>
_______________________________________________
GOAL mailing list
[email protected]
http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal

Reply via email to