With so many replies to Cornell, here may be consensus statement around
which many Goan Catholics participating in this thread may find
acceptable.

I do not want to sound a linguist. But at the same time the issue of
caste seems to affect our Goan society, judging by the posts it
generates on the net. Hence, rather than loosely / pejoratively calling
Goan Catholics 'casteist' (and worse still drag the Church into it) or
'Catdus' (presumably Catholics who behave like Hindus) we should more
correctly state: 

"Some Goans still continue to have some deep-seated caste instincts and
unfortunately a few of them happen to be Catholics." 

This makes a lot more sense without wounding any individual, group of
individuals, segments of Goan society or Goan institutions. Hopefully we
then can continue to have a more intellectual and constructive dialogue
on finding some specific solutions. Regards, GL, Utica, NY.


Reply via email to