Dear Goanetters,
 
     Dotor Jose-bab Colaco made a very important comment in a recent
     posting . He says :
     " Wish they would not repost propaganda from blatantly prejudiced
     sites - without checking for possible veracity or possibility...of what
     is hearsay "
 
     Now, please have another look at a document titled "Broken peace "
     widely circulated on many platforms including this one.
     This, according to the author, was a " fact finding " mission to try
     and understand the root causes of communal violence.The author
     starts by saying that it was ensured that the enquiry is carried out
     " objectively "
 
     
     http://www.sacw.net/DC/CommunalismCollection/ArticlesArchive/brpeace.pdf
 
 
      My first question is , can any document of such sensitive nature
      be factual and objective if it contains  " hearsay " statements like 
      the one's starting off as below ?
      My next question will follow in a future posting ( depending on the
      answers I get to question 1 )
 
 
      as one of the intellectuals we interviewed told us
 
      shaikh nissar of curchorem recollected how as a child studying in 
      7th standard
 
      according to ramesh gauns
 
      one of the people we interviewed ( he did not want to be named )
      told us
 
      our informant said
 
      c b vaz of assolna has calculated
 
      several people we interviewed , including hindus in bicholim , mupusa
      and panaji told us
 
      our investigations have revealed
 
      we were shocked to learn
 
      one muslim leader we talked to in vasco said
 
      the hindu friend said
 
      another muslim leader in curchorem told us
 
      none of the muslims mentioned the fact
 
      many muslims we talked to said
 
      kabir told us / kabir felt / kabir thinks
 
      another muslim businessman ( who did not want to be named ) said
 
      the muslim shopkeeper told us
 
      there were three young men ad a woman who risked speaking to us
 
      the others sitting told us
 
      after speaking to the people of the village , we found that
 
      when enquired,the villagers said
 
      however,when we enquired elsewhere,we found that
 
 
      luv and regards,
      anand
 
     ( Dr Anand Virgincar )
 
 
_________________________________________________________________
Get Hotmail on your mobile, text MSN to 63463!
http://mobile.uk.msn.com/pc/mail.aspx

Reply via email to