On Oct 13, 2013, at 12:31 PM, Ana Maria Fernandes <amferns_n...@hotmail.com> 
wrote:

"This incident happened when my grandmother was alive. A young five year old 
girl suffered from bronchities. The girl lived in my neighbour hood. My 
grandmother advised the parents to put ventos. The father took the girl to a 
good doctor who got her admitted and put her on antiobiotics and within two 
days the child was discharged fully cured. Four months later again the child 
got the same sickness. could not breathe, again my shameless grandmother told 
the mother and father to put ventos. They again got her admitted and within two 
days stay in the hospital the child reached home. Again five months to be 
precise the child aMy grgain got admitted in the hospital. My grandmother 
shouted at the parents but they took her to be a senile woman. My grandmother 
stopped telling the parents . after five and half years of this exercise the 
child was admitted this time .They had to remove the greasy mucus like yellow 
substance from the lungs and they kept the child for nearly ten days. first 
three days on oxygen. The child became weak and could not attend to school. The 
child was discharged but of an on they had to admit the child to remove the 
flem in the lungs.  think the child had developed Pleursy. I am not sure. and 
on 10th of June 2000 the child passed away. When my grandma visited them she 
told the parents " You killed your lovely child." My grandmother passed away. I 
still remember her remedy. I have not given any dose to my children from birth. 
Do you know that when BCG dose is given the child many times suffer from cold 
and fever ? Many people grumbled at me for not giving polio and other rubbish 
doses. My mother did not give us any of those and for last forty years I never 
got polio, cold or fever (that too once in blue moon)so too my children. Can 
dotor colaco speak on this "

RESPONSE:

Dear Ana Marie,

Sure!

I will speak on this after you clarify a few points for me, please.

While I am happy to speak about this topic at any venue, I prefer to be as 
fully informed as possible. Not doing so would make me an uninformed alleged 
expert on healthcare.

My queries:

1: What is Ventos?

Are you absolutely sure that
2: the child was fully cured after 2 days of antibiotics?

If you know
3: What was the stated cause of death of the child eg TB etc?

jc

Reply via email to