Hi Robert, Yes I have tried HTTP request via curl. That yields a response in about 200ms.
On Friday, 5 May 2023 at 22:56:58 UTC+10 Robert Engels wrote: > Have you tried using curl as the client in order to narrow down the > problem? > > On May 5, 2023, at 7:45 AM, envee <neeraj....@gmail.com> wrote: > > An update. > > The VM on which I am running has 40 vCPUs. > I changed my GOMAXPROCS to a lower value of 8. > And also changed my client to use 90 HTTP/2 connections towards the HTTP/2 > server. > With this setup, I can now achieve about 9000 Txns per second. > However, if I go any higher than that, my client starts throwing the > "context deadline exceeded" errors. I am sure that the responses are > received by the client well within the timeout of 7 seconds. > When I observe the CPU utilization of my client process, it only uses > about 300% vCPU i.e. 3 out of 40 vCPUs. > Still, I don't understand why I cannot achieve higher throughput than 9000 > per second. > Here is a sample output from the *atop* utility. As seen below, only 257% > shows as CPU utilization. > > Is this because goroutines are not getting context switched onto a logical > processor or thread. I thought if there is so much CPU available, then > context switching should be very fast and not an issue at all. > Thus leading to timeouts ? > > ATOP - myserver 2023/05/05 22:16:19 > y--------P---- > 10s elapsed > PRC | sys 6.63s | user 21.56s | | #proc 543 | #trun > 4 | #tslpi 639 | | #tslpu 0 | #zombie 0 | clones > 11 | | no procacct | > CPU | sys 61% | user 213% | irq 4% | idle 3724% | wait > 0% | steal 0% | guest 0% | | ipc notavail | cycl > unknown | curf 3.00GHz | curscal ?% | > CPL | avg1 2.28 | avg5 2.40 | | avg15 2.45 | > | | csw 656705 | intr 515996 | | > | numcpu 40 | | > MEM | tot 503.7G | free 468.6G | cache 26.9G | dirty 0.1M | buff > 1.0G | slab 1.4G | slrec 1.2G | shmem 4.1G | shrss 117.0M | vmbal > 0.0M | hptot 0.0M | hpuse 0.0M | > SWP | tot 4.0G | free 4.0G | | | > | | | | | > | vmcom 6.0G | vmlim 255.8G | > LVM | g_vd0-lv_var | busy 0% | read 0 | | write > 158 | KiB/r 0 | KiB/w 4 | MBr/s 0.0 | MBw/s 0.1 | > | avq 5.00 | avio 0.01 ms | > DSK | sda | busy 0% | read 0 | | write > 122 | KiB/r 0 | KiB/w 5 | MBr/s 0.0 | MBw/s 0.1 | > | avq 2.00 | avio 0.01 ms | > NET | transport | tcpi 181070 | tcpo 289884 | udpi 18 | udpo > 18 | tcpao 0 | tcppo 26 | tcprs 556 | tcpie 0 | tcpor > 1 | udpnp 0 | udpie 0 | > NET | network | ipi 181092 | ipo 201839 | | ipfrw > 0 | deliv 181091 | | | | > | icmpi 0 | icmpo 0 | > NET | bond1 0% | pcki 181057 | pcko 290688 | sp 20 Gbps | si 16 > Mbps | so 190 Mbps | coll 0 | mlti 0 | erri 0 | erro > 0 | drpi 0 | drpo 0 | > NET | net2 0% | pcki 181056 | pcko 290688 | sp 20 Gbps | si 16 > Mbps | so 190 Mbps | coll 0 | mlti 0 | erri 0 | erro > 0 | drpi 0 | drpo 0 | > > PID TID SYSCPU USRCPU VGROW RGROW > RUID EUID ST EXC THR S > CPUNR CPU CMD 1/1 > 40753 - 4.08s 21.52s 0K -11.7M > mtx mtx -- - 15 S > 20 *257% 5gclient* > 40753 40753 0.00s 0.00s 0K -11.7M > mtx mtx -- - 1 S > 20 0% 5gclient > 40753 40754 0.00s 0.00s 0K -11.7M > mtx mtx -- - 1 S > 5 0% 5gclient > 40753 40755 0.00s 0.00s 0K -11.7M > mtx mtx -- - 1 S > 3 0% 5gclient > 40753 40756 0.00s 0.00s 0K -11.7M > mtx mtx -- - 1 S > 21 0% 5gclient > 40753 40757 0.45s 2.35s 0K -11.7M > mtx mtx -- - 1 S > 6 28% 5gclient > 40753 40758 0.44s 2.31s 0K -11.7M > mtx mtx -- - 1 S > 20 28% 5gclient > 40753 40759 0.44s 2.52s 0K -11.7M > mtx mtx -- - 1 S > 0 30% 5gclient > 40753 40760 0.36s 1.80s 0K -11.7M > mtx mtx -- - 1 S > 28 22% 5gclient > 40753 40761 0.41s 2.04s 0K -11.7M > mtx mtx -- - 1 S > 9 25% 5gclient > 40753 40762 0.48s 2.46s 0K -11.7M > mtx mtx -- - 1 R > 1 30% 5gclient > 40753 40763 0.00s 0.00s 0K -11.7M > mtx mtx -- - 1 S > 23 0% 5gclient > 40753 40764 0.45s 2.48s 0K -11.7M > mtx mtx -- - 1 S > 2 29% 5gclient > 40753 40765 0.21s 1.17s 0K -11.7M > mtx mtx -- - 1 S > 1 14% 5gclient > 40753 40766 0.45s 2.46s 0K -11.7M > mtx mtx -- - 1 S > 5 29% 5gclient > 40753 41140 0.39s 1.90s 0K -11.7M > mtx mtx -- - 1 R > 29 23% 5gclient > > > > > On Friday, 5 May 2023 at 08:33:12 UTC+10 envee wrote: > >> Hi All, >> I have an application which sends HTTP requests at a rate of say 6000 per >> second. In addition, my application also has about 100K goroutines and >> these 6000 requests are basically issued by a subset of these goroutines. >> >> When I increase the rate to more than 6000, I get the error : >> "context deadline exceeded (Client.Timeout exceeded while awaiting >> headers)" >> >> From a PCAP trace, I have seen that the server does respond within the >> timeout (which I've set to 7s), but the application is not able to probably >> finish reading the response. >> >> From the code of the HTTP client, I see that there is a timer/ticker >> which is run in the background for every request. >> >> My understanding is that the goroutine which issued the HTTP request was >> not able to get scheduled on a Processor/Thread and hence timed out. >> >> Possibly due to multiple goroutines becoming Runnable, but not being >> scheduled ? >> >> Is my understanding of why I see timeouts correct ? >> >> If a goroutine starts a timer/ticker, then if it gets taken off a P as it >> is waiting for a Network I/O response, will the timer also pause when it is >> removed from a P by the scheduler ? >> > -- > You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups > "golang-nuts" group. > To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an > email to golang-nuts...@googlegroups.com. > To view this discussion on the web visit > https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/golang-nuts/593823f5-1be6-4d60-9341-6fbc3da82c55n%40googlegroups.com > > <https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/golang-nuts/593823f5-1be6-4d60-9341-6fbc3da82c55n%40googlegroups.com?utm_medium=email&utm_source=footer> > . > > -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "golang-nuts" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to golang-nuts+unsubscr...@googlegroups.com. To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/golang-nuts/648add9e-cf1b-44f2-8922-b8ee4a2a4c22n%40googlegroups.com.
