Mungkin penyelesainnya simpel kali ya Pak Iqbal, jika sistem dari atas sampai bawah berjalan sesuai dengan fungsinya dan bersih dari "PungLi", maka semuanya akan baik-baik saja.
Mungkin ada wakil rakyat di milist ini yang lebih tahu penyelesainnya? Tulisan hanya sekedar curhatan [:)] . Sri Jakarta --- In gorontalomaju2020@yahoogroups.com, iqbal makmur <kaizen...@...> wrote: > > Tulisan ibu Sri dibawah saya kira patut didiskusikan, Pertanyaannya adalah > bagaimana hukum memberikan uang pada pengemis yang katanya banyak yang > terorganisir dan profesional. Apakah kita harus mengikuti anjuran pemerintah > untuk menyerahkan uang kita ke lembaga2 amal yang ada yang katanya juga > mengambil keuntungan pribadi dengan berkedok legal charity? > > Iqbal > Yogyakarta > > > > ________________________________ > From: joustin0708 jen...@... > To: gorontalomaju2020@yahoogroups.com > Sent: Thu, August 12, 2010 12:33:20 AM > Subject: [GM2020] Beware, They're Fake Homeless... > > > "Don't give your money to them, they're fake!" She warned me in a convince > expression on her face and with a bit persuade tunes on her voice. The fact is > she's not the first person told me not to give money to any homeless, and > anywhere place I go. Well, isn't that a bit a 'punishment' of campaign for > homeless?, particularly only to give a penny of yours to some unlucky people on > the road? > > But I gotta tell you the truth that this 'punishment' of champaign is legally > supported by some local goverment regions in Indonesia. "Don't spend your money > to them -- Give it to a legal charity" says an ads tense on a big board hang on > along of the main road with a picture of homeless. A question in my mind when I > read that big ads, and perhaps, you might ask this question too: "What kinds of > legal charity they aim to?" > > Because I never known regarding a legal charity in Indonesia, or maybe I'm the > only one who misinformation about this. Or, should I share my story regarding > a charity where I worked with a couple of years ago? Maybe I should ... > > I was working in a charity which the owner possess a title 'Hajjah' *when a > woman goes to Mekkah to do the fifth of the pillar of the Islam, she'll be > titled a 'Hajjah'* The charity had registered legally at local goverment --- > the registration number was mentioned on the board of the front of charity > office, to ensure people that the charity wasn't fake. Everything regarding the > charity intitution was proceed due procedure. From the very beginning, I was > already uncomfortable with the situation i.e. the building shared with where > her big family lived. Yet, her sons in law were unemployeed; and together with > her husband she ran the charity. And from some surrounded people told me that > the owner didn't really help slummer. > > However I kept working with them until 1 month as that was my experience as > fresh graduate. And then I decided to resign when I found that they make a > charity to make money for themselves. > > I know we can't take them all in the same level as a bad one, but tell me the > truth what's not difficult to posses and make something in Indonesia? even for > something that legally? And yet, how about the rumours about making business > between the charity and the local goverment? > > Anyway, back to the point... > > Its just simply situation: they're homeless, no home, no food, no money --- and > I just want to give my Rp 5,000 to them --- Do you think I should give my Rp > 5,000 to charity first, and then waiting the charity to give to them? Is that > the right way to do? > > OR, I heard what you said: " They have a boss, group, or rich, or bla, > bla....." > > When a 9-year-old begged her hands with innocently gaze at me, her > long-unwashed- and untidy hair, smelly, and skinny body asked me money while I > sat with two friends of mine in a Lesehan Yogya, and surrounded by loads of > nice foods. > > Should I ignore her by telling her: "Listen, I'm a good citizen, I want you to > ask money to a charity where my money give with" ----- ???? --- Or "Listen, I > don't trust you. You must have a boss" ---- ???? ---- > > I think we need grow up soon before this earth ends up by too many greedy > people..... (Sri Agustiani). > > > JKT, 23.55-110810 >
