I would argue that all the figures on the right are "better"
interpretations for those note sequences.
The podatus initio debilis (the first one) is more like the Solesmes
figure and is not easily confused with the liquescent clivis (what you
have as ge~). Compare -eg and ge~ in the old version versus the new.
I honestly can't remember any instances in any of the current books
where there is an ascent of notes in a stair-step fashion without there
being a podatus, a virga, or a graphic separation to break it up
visually (or it being a different neume entirely), so the newer figures
for the latter two examples, I feel, are more representative of what you
would typically find in a book. In any case, if you really want the
stair-step, you can always break up the notes with ! marks.
Just my opinion of course.
Henry
On Tuesday, 10 March 2015 at 11:13:06 pm -0500, Brother Gabriel-Marie wrote:
> Hmmm... I recompiled my gabc cheat sheet and notices a few
> differences between the way Gregorio 2.3 and 2.4.2 built the
> pdf.
>
> The gabc file was the same in both cases (attached).
>
> So, version 2.3 (cheat-sheet.pdf) on the left, 2.4.2
> (main-lualatex.pdf) on the right.
>
> I think that the newer version on the right might be in error?
>
>
> I think the newer version on the right is in error.
>
>
> Again.
>
>
> Maybe I'm doing something wrong; but other than these
> differences, everything else seems okay.
> % !TEX TS-program = lualatex
> % !TEX encoding = UTF-8
>
> % This is a simple template for a LuaLaTeX document using gregorio scores.
>
> \documentclass[11pt]{article} % use larger type; default would be 10pt
>
> % usual packages loading:
> \usepackage{luatextra}
> \usepackage{fontspec}
> \usepackage{graphicx} % support the \includegraphics command and options
> \usepackage{geometry} % See geometry.pdf to learn the layout options. There
> are lots.
> \usepackage{gregoriotex} % for gregorio score inclusion
> \usepackage{fullpage} % to reduce the margins
> \usepackage[latin]{babel} % choose the language of the document here
>
> % to change the font to something better, you can install the kpfonts package
> (if not already installed). To do so
> % go open the "TeX Live Manager" in the Menu Start->All Programs->TeX Live
> 2010
>
> % here we begin the document
> \begin{document}
> \pagestyle{empty} %removes page numbering
> \greblockcustos % no custos at the end
>
> % The title:
> \begin{center}\begin{huge}\textsc{Gregorio gabc Code
> Sheet}\end{huge}\end{center}
>
> % Here we set the space around the initial.
> % Please report to http://home.gna.org/gregorio/gregoriotex/details for more
> details and options
> \setspaceafterinitial{2.2mm plus 0em minus 0em}
> \setspacebeforeinitial{2.2mm plus 0em minus 0em}
>
> % Here we set the initial font. Change 43 if you want a bigger initial.
> \def\greinitialformat#1{ {\fontsize{43}{43}\selectfont #1} }
>
> % We set the annotations above the initial.
> \gresetfirstlineaboveinitial{\small \textsc{\textbf{line1}}}{\small
> \textsc{\textbf{line2}}}
>
> % We set red lines here, comment it if you want black ones.
> \redlines
>
> % We type a text in the top right corner of the score:
> \commentary{{\small \emph{Commentary goes here}}}
>
> % and finally we include the score. The file must be in the same directory as
> this one.
> \includescore[f]{GregorioCodeSheet}
>
> \end{document}
> % !TEX TS-program = gregorio
> % !TEX encoding = UTF-8
>
> % The first part of the score is called the header, you can input some useful
> informations here:
> name: Gabc Cheat Sheet;
> date: 2013;
> transcriber: Brother Gabriel-Marie;
> transcription-date: 2013;
> style: modern;
> def-m1:%test72;
> initial-style: 0;
> annotation:Test;
> annotation:1;
> %%
> %-------------------------------------------------------------------
> %
>
> %To force a line break and justify the staff, place (z) at the end
> %adding (z ) will add space before the justification mark
>
> %scale
> (c4) a[ scale](a) b(b) c(c) d(d) e(e) f(f) g(g) h(h) i(i) j(j) k(k) l(l)
> m(m) (::) (g) /[neumatic cut](/) (g) //(//) (g) ( :: z)
>
> %puncti & various glyphs
> g[ single notes](g) gv(gv) gw(gw) go(go) g<(g<) g>(g>) g~(g~) g.(g.)
> g..(g..) g'(g') g_(g_) g_0(g_0) go<sp>~</sp>(go~) go<(go<) gs(gs) gs<(gs<)
> G(G) G<sp>~</sp>(G~) G>(G>) (::)(z)
>
> %clefs, pitch notes, custos
> c1[ clefs](c1) c2(c2) c3(c3) c4(c4) f2(f2) f3(f3) f4(f4) cb3(cb3)
> (::) [breathe]( ) `(`) ( :: ) gx[pitch](gx) gy(gy) g#(g#) z0::c4[custos
> inside staff](z0::c4)( z)
>
> %breaks and separations
> ;[ breaks](;) :(:) ::(::) ;1[separations](;1) ;2(;2) ;3(;3) ;4(;4)
> ;5(;5) ;6(;6) ,_(,_) :'(:') ( z)
>
> %podatus, torculus
> gh[podatus](gh) gi(gi) ig(ig) gh_(gh_) g'h(g'h) gh'(gh') gqi(gqi) g'qi(g'qi)
> hg(hg) eh..(eh..) (::) efe(efe) ghg[torculus](ghg) gh_g_(gh_g_)
> g_h_g_(g_h_g_) e_i_h_(e_i_h_)(::)(z)
>
> %liquescents, qualisma, porrectus
> eg<sp>~</sp>[liquescent & debilis](eg~) ge<sp>~</sp>(ge~)
> geg<sp>~</sp>(geg~) -gh(-gh) gh<sp>~</sp>(gh~) -fgf(-fgf)
> fgf<sp>~</sp>(fgf~)(::) gw[qualisma](gw) gwi(gwi) gwig(gwig) gWi(gWi)
> (::) ge[porrectus](ge) geg(geg) gege(gege) (::z)
>
> %neum formations
> fgh(fgh ) f!gh(f!gh ) f!g'h(f!g'h ) fg!hv(fg!hv ) f/gh(f/gh ) f//gh(f//gh
> ) f gh(f gh ) fghi(fghi) fg!hi(gg!hi) f!gh!i(f!gh!i) (:) gvF'E~(gvF'E~)(::Z)
>
> %extraneous notes
> g(g) gr(gr) gR(gR ) gr0(gr0) (;) gr1(gr1) gr2(gr2) gr3(gr3) gr4(gr4) gr5(gr5)
> (;) grr1(grr1) grr2(grr2) grr3(grr3) grr4(grr4) grr5(grr5) (;) (z)
> gr0r1(gr0r1) gr0r2(gr0r2) gr0r3(gr0r3) gr0r4(gr0r4 ) gr0r5(gr0r5 ) (;)
> gR0r1(gR0r1) gR0r2(gR0r2) gR0r3(gR0r3) gR0r4(gR0r4 ) gR0r5(gR0r5 ) (::)
> gss(gss) hsss(hsss) (::) (z)
>
> %
>
> %-------------------------------------------------------------------
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Gregorio-users mailing list
> [email protected]
> https://mail.gna.org/listinfo/gregorio-users
_______________________________________________
Gregorio-users mailing list
[email protected]
https://mail.gna.org/listinfo/gregorio-users
