Hi, Christopher Baines <[email protected]> skribis:
> Ludovic Courtès <[email protected]> writes: > >> Christopher Baines <[email protected]> skribis: >> >>> [email protected] writes: >>> >>>> civodul pushed a commit to branch master >>>> in repository guix. >>>> >>>> commit e45306c1982aee194243cf661295c7ca776d879f >>>> Author: Ludovic Courtès <[email protected]> >>>> AuthorDate: Thu Apr 20 10:38:37 2023 +0200 >>>> >>>> services: postgresql: Add default package. [...] >> Oh, my bad. I found it weird that the default value would be found in >> the service and not in the configuration object. The result is that >> there is a default value, just not where you’d expect it. >> >> But yeah, I understand the rationale of the commit above, so we should >> probably revert to that and add a comment explaining why there’s no >> default. >> >> I wonder how we can make sure that users can still write (say): >> >> (service cuirass-service-type) >> >> without having to explicitly specify which postgresql version they want >> to use. >> >> WDYT? > > Yeah, we're just moving the problem of matching up the PostgreSQL > software and data at the moment, but I think it's still preferable to > make the problem clear in the configuration and when reconfiguring > rather than delaying things to when the service doesn't start. Yeah, OK. So I guess we can revert e45306c1982aee194243cf661295c7ca776d879f and add a comment explaining the lack of a default value. If that sounds good to you, please go ahead or let me know if I should do it. > It would be good to at least have some Guix specific documentation on > how to migrate from one PostgreSQL version to another, and ideally this > could be integrated in to the service somehow. That's the blocking issue > to providing defaults here, we're just setting the user up for the > service not starting at some point in the future when we change the > default version of PostgreSQL. I’m not really in a position to help but I agree! Thanks, Ludo’.
