Hugo Buddelmeijer via "Development of GNU Guix and the GNU System
distribution." <[email protected]> writes:

> Very nice!  It seems to have some false positives when running on Guix 
> itself (1909dd5b1958e4b98e17e47cb722aae240a622bf):

Thanks for testing out the extension.  I've made a new release addressing
all the issues you raised.  I've already submitted the corresponding PR
in Guix proper to update the package.

[1] https://codeberg.org/guix/guix/pulls/12231

> guix shell --pure nss-certs guile guix guix-removal-reporter -- guix 
> removals
>
> - It notices that go-github-com-rogpeppe-go-internal-1.14 is removed in 
> #12073, and subsequently incorrectly lists all packages that have 
> go-github-com-rogpeppe-go-internal (without -1.14) as a dependency

Right, it was printing the package name, I've adjusted the code so it
prints the symbol being removed.

> - It notices sbcl-kaputt and cl-kaputt are removed in #11946, and then 
> complains that cl-kaputt will be affected by the sbcl-kaputt removal.

Yes, I've overlooked that a package should not be considered as affected
by the removal if it's removed from within the same PR.  The new release
adresses this also.

> It also does not list all removals:
>
> - Twinkle is proposed to be removed in #10319, but it is not mentioned. 
> It doesn't have any dependents though, so maybe that's why.

I see, I forgot to increase the forgejo request limit, it was set to
5. I've set it to Codeberg's limit of 50 items per request.

> Nevertheless, `guix removals` is already useful with these shortcomings.

I've glad you find it helpful!


Best regards,
Sergio

  • A boon for our de... Sergio Pastor Pérez
    • Re: A boon f... Fredrik Salomonsson
    • Re: A boon f... Development of GNU Guix and the GNU System distribution.
      • Re: A bo... Sergio Pastor Pérez
        • Re: ... Development of GNU Guix and the GNU System distribution.
          • ... Sergio Pastor Pérez
            • ... Development of GNU Guix and the GNU System distribution.
              • ... Sergio Pastor Pérez

Reply via email to