Hi,

Sergio Pastor Pérez <[email protected]> writes:

> Hi,
>
> Maxim Cournoyer <[email protected]> writes:
>
>> Why would we need such a tag though? In my view, if a contribution is
>> suspected of having been LLM-generated, it should be clarified with the
>> contributor, and if confirmed, point them to our policy (info "(guix)
>> Copyright Matters") and close the PR.
>
> To my understanding, this line is not so clear to draw and sometimes
> requires some investigation.  It could imagine it would be helpful for
> committers to know if someone already did some investigation, even if
> they didn't engage into a discussion with the submitter.  This should
> help alleviate the burden of committers.

Just to make sure, we're talking about whether changes made to Guix
itself were LLM-generated, not whether a new software packaged was
authored with the help of an LLM, correct?  If that is the case,
whatever investigation you can do, unless you somehow have trained your
eyes on the output of common models to know their quirks, in the end,
you must trust what the contributor says, just as you would trust
someone claiming they wrote this by themselves and didn't take it from
someone else.

I worry that having such a tag would encourage witch hunting, which
would definitely be a bad vibe to have in our community.  An honest,
direct question to the author and a gentle approach would seem best to
me.  Of course if the same person keeps disregarding the rule, there can
be an escalation, ultimately a ban.

-- 
Thanks,
Maxim

Reply via email to