Jonathan asked about the use of flight:
> As much as I like transforming mecha, they're even less credible than
> regular mecha are - and even that's going to be a stretch, given the
> potential alternatives.  In particular, for the same mass that is
> required for leg drivetrains, you can get a lift system that doesn't
> require any reaction mass to be carried in the vehicle.  OTOH, such a
> system requires an atmosphere to be useful; if a significant portion
> of possible destinations are on vacuum worlds, legs will have the
> edge.

And Anthony made the same point:
> Heh. Transforming mecha are a staple of the genre, but they really 
> really don't work well. Rather than adding legs, it would be much easier 
> (and more generally effective) to add an air-breathing engine (ducted 
> fan or fusion air-ram) and have indefinite flight endurance.

The setting deliberately included many non-earthlike worlds, surely 
some are marslike with significant gravity and very thin atmosphere.
TL10 super reactionless thrusters would be perfect for those worlds, 
but they are not part of the setting -- this is no 'selective tech 
amnesia' to support Mecha because reactionless thrusters are magic 
superscience to start with, you'd have to justify taking them in, 
not justify leaving them out. 

Jonathan continues:
> Of course, said worlds are also likely to be low-gravity; so a design
> with legs ought to be prepared to do a lot of hopping along low-G
> trajectories.  You probably also want to equip them with a winch
> system of some sort for use in micro-gravity and freefall
> environments, so that they're not completely out of options if they
> have no reaction mass to work with.  Again, the biggest advantage of a
> mecha will be its versatility: the thing can hop over obstacles, climb
> up obstacles that are too tall to hop over, and outmaneuver anything
> else on the ground (and most things in the air). 

The fighter should always keep enough fuel to return to the carrier. 
In a tactical emergency, it could use the docking portion of that
orbit-and-dock reserve in combat and refuel from an orbital tanker.

Note to self -- remember to add a refueling probe. 

> With its arms and
> hands, it can do construction and combat engineering work when it
> isn't wielding a mecha rifle in a fight: if the military that it's
> assigned to is one that's devoted to helping out the friendly locals
> beyond merely protecting them from enemy combat units, such additional
> capabilities will be crucial.

I'm trying to justify the Mecha as a highly specialized spaceborne
invader. Not a pound for hearts and minds ...

> Ve2-style fusion rockets imply similar fusion jets, which greatly
> interfere with the viability of legged vehicles.  Why walk when you
> can fly?

A TL10 fusion rocket fighter will have 2 to 5 g-hours of thrust, 
depending on the ratio of reaction mass. A 'flying AFV' will be 
at the lower end of the scale. Call it 18 km/s going in, 18 km/s
going home, two hours hovering on station on a half-G world.

Pauli replied to Jon:
> While walking, a vehicle has; lower sensor signatures, easy access
> to suitable terrain features for cover, better dodge score, lower
> energy consumption, longer operational endurance and better stability
> in bad weather.

My point exactly.

> Vehicle which can both fly and walk offers an impressive width of
> tactical flexibility. Reconfigurable aerospace/ground mecha are a
> very theoretic futuristic design concept for sure, but as a concept
> this can be fairly plausible - With fusion rockets or even with
> reactionless/conversion thrusters available, IMHO the added tactical
> flexibility can easily justify the design (if it is indeed practically
> doable with the settings technology).. I am not saying that it would
> totally replace cheaper dedicated fighters or tanks, but it would offer
> a more widespread selection of abilities - Possibly the ultimate amongst
> multienvironmental design concepts.

With TL11+ reactionless thrust, there are fewer reasons for walking.

And Brandon asked:
> Is there a reason you can't use the hyperdives for going between planets 
> in-system?

Then you could try to argue that aerospace fighters should have 
hyperdrive as well, including specialized transformable ones. I 
don't want to spend those 2+ tons for hyperdrive and power, so 
I remove the temptation and level the playing field.

Note to self -- see if the TL11 Mecha should be FTL-capable :-)

> I'd wonder why planetary assaults aren't primarily conducted by robotic 
> drones.

Because that would diminish the role of human heroes. A deliberate 
setting choice, but not one crippling or supporting regular tanks 
compared to Mecha.
_______________________________________________
GurpsNet-L mailing list <[email protected]>
http://mail.sjgames.com/mailman/listinfo/gurpsnet-l

Reply via email to