On Sat, Jan 30, 2010 at 2:16 PM, Onno Meyer <[email protected]> wrote:

> > > Historically, the caravel came earlier than the schooner,
> > > but is it also easier to build?
> > >
> > At TL2, you're not going to build a caravel.  You're going to be building
> > clinker built ships, which don't have the rigidity to sail well up wind.
>
> Three different answers, one semantic, one on game mechanics,
> and the real explanation which influenced which optional game
> mechanics I wanted to use:
>
> * Of course a 'real caravel' is TL3-4, and a 'real schooner' is
>  TL4-5. I was thinking of the basic sail plan when wrote that,
>  a ship with two lateen sails or a ship with two lugsails, but
>  lacking jibs and topsails. An 'anachonistic schooner' or an
>  'anachronistic caravel', coming close in look-and-feel but of
>  course less capable.
>

Construction of the hull  plays a big part in the sail plan.  Caravels are
carvel built, which means they're made of frames, covered with planks that
abut each other (like a wood floor, more or less).  The frames provide a
method of supporting the rather strong transverse forces that result from
sailing upwind.  clinker built (lapstrake to some people) ships have less
rigid framing, and less ability to sail up wind, even if they ahd the same
sail plan.  The other early form of ship builidng, "sewn" ships, as used in
egypt, babylon, and elsewhere (ancestors of the dhow), also have little
transverse strength, and limited ability to sail upwind.



> * The VXi rules give break points for the Minimum Upwind Angle
>  modifiers at TL5 and TL7. However, TL3+ has new rigs with a
>  significantly lower MUA than TL2.
>
> * I thought that dhows (built hull-first, frame-later) could
>  tack if they had to, but avoided it when possible because
>  of the awkwardness of moving the lateen to the other side
>  of the mast.
>
> Part of it.  They also have to have a different set of sails to beat upwind
than to run downwind.  (They've got a different three-dimensional shape.
Ones deeper than the other, but I can't remember hich is which.)


>  So I simply took a medium hull, much stronger than a classic
>  TL2 galley, and assumed that I had enough strength. My hull
>  is significantly heavier than the caravel in Low-Tech, and
>  thus slower.
>
>
It's not just weight, it's also getting the forces into the hull in ways
that the materials the hull is made of can support.  Wood is orthotropic:
it's got vastly different strengths with the grain or perpendicular to it.
Tensile strength of wood is quite high along the grain, compressive strength
is adequate, but the shear strength is low.  Perpendicular to the grain,
tensile strength is nearly zero, compressive strength is lower, but still
usable, and shear strength is very high.  Making and rigging a wooden boat
requires understanding these things, which is why the get better as
technology advances.


> I think I'll write "She can even tack upwind, though not as
> well as a historical schooner."
>
> > > Can there be cramped rowing stations?
> > I don't think you're going to be able to do this at TL2.  Late TL3 or TL4
> > is
> > going to be needed to build strong enough ships.
>
> Then I'll make them roomy. With superior access (VXi23), that
> takes my remaining space, but if they can sit on sea chests
> or the like the space can be used to extend the living areas
> when the oars are shipped.
>

Lots of ships were rowed not below deck, but from the deck.

-- 
David Scheidt
[email protected]
_______________________________________________
GurpsNet-L mailing list <[email protected]>
http://mail.sjgames.com/mailman/listinfo/gurpsnet-l

Reply via email to