Hi there. I sell both solutions as part of my work. I like them for
what they are and what works best for you will depend a bit on your
over all impressions of both.
The mobile phone solution is superior to the voice sense on paper in
almost every way. It's far cheeper, faster, smaller, and packed with
more features. I have no trouble checking my email on the i-paq
phones that make up most of my mobile experience. Mobile speak is a
bit laim on the web in it's windows mobile incarnation, but I'm not
really all that kean on mobile internet anyway because it's very
expensive here in Canada.
I have a braille display, and so most of my comparisons have more to
do with the braille sense than the actual voice sense. Connecting a
bluetooth braille display is not seemless like throwing up a braille
sense and turning it on is, but the astronomical savings in cost and
space make up for it for my needs. I'm also a huge elloquence
detracter and the shudder of revoltion when I turned on a braille
sense for the first time a couple of years ago and heard elloquence
blathering at me... ughch. Fortunately for me I never use speech and
braille at the same time, so my first act on using a bs for myself for
the first time is to mute the speech. Mobile speak comes with dektalk
speech which is not the best sounding speech in the world, but which
has performance and stability going for it. It also comes with your
choice of extremely high end digital voices which used to be a
considerable hit on performance but since the emersion of windows
mobile 6 and the phones that run it they have gotten really seemless.
If you want a full on mobile tool, you get mobile speak and a good
windows mobile phone imho. If you want a full on note taking device
or writing tool like a perkins brailler replacement you get something
like the vs or the bs. They are each the best at what they do. I
just think they are ment for two different audiences.
Best,
erik burggraaf
A+ sertified technician and user support consultant.
Phone: 888-255-5194
Email: [email protected]
On 12-Apr-09, at 1:19 AM, Steve Gladstone wrote:
Hi All,
I have a VS and looking to get a new cell phone with mobile speak
software. I'm interested in habits. I would like to hear from those
of you who have a VS or BS and also use a phone with screen reader.
Specifically, when you are away from home, do you tend to use your
VS or cell phone most often to manage your email? I'll take your
response off line at [email protected].
Thanks,
Steve
No virus found in this outgoing message.
Checked by AVG.
Version: 7.5.557 / Virus Database: 270.11.52/2053 - Release Date:
4/10/2009 6:27 PM