Hi Donna, I'm not saying you're rong necessarily. Most of my training clients are seniors who went blind later in life and lack of interest or lack of sensativity won't allow them to use braille. My experience with children in the last year and a half or so that I had this gig comes to exactly 2, and they are both heavy braille users a la perkins stile. I'm teaching an 8 year old to type on a qwerty now and she is well on her way towards grade two braille. Probably has been using a perkins and braille since age 5 or earlier. The other case was a 11 year old boy who is comfortable on both by the time I set up his equipment.

There's not really much room for a monitor on a desk in a classroom situation unless you give the blind kid his or her own corner of the classroom. That used to happen with me because my books were so big, but I suspect that we are moving kids towards text books in braille on their note taking device because of portability and ease of production. The smallest monitor we can get now here in Ontario is 20 inches. Some 17 inch are still floating around in bargain computer stores here in the city, but you won't find a nice 12 inch flat screen anywhere. If the blind kid is sitting in a regular school desk with the chair attached by a bar on one side, then they have about a square foot of space, maybe a little more. That's not enough space to open a braille book, and in the case of the 8 year old, it may be even less because her school desk will be scaled down from what I remember from my high school days. There's no room for a small monitor on the desk, and there may not be a convenient plug to plug it in to. Plus they move the kids around a lot now, and this tiny little kid can't cary around a monitor, even a small one. The display is perfect because she can scribe during group activities and others in her group can read back what she scribes, and teachers can look over her shoulder if they want. I would have loved something like that in my school days, but my braille 'n speak 640 didn't ship with one.

Best,

erik burggraaf
A+ sertified technician and user support consultant.
Phone: 888-255-5194
Email: [email protected]

On 19-May-09, at 10:25 AM, Donna Goodin wrote:

I don't know, Eric, I think you could make that same argument the other way. I suspect that more users don't use the screen than do, so in some ways it doesn't make sense to have it taking up space and resources. After all, in a classroom situation, you could always hook the unit up to an external monitor, and the teacher would then have a full-sized screen, instead of the little tiny one on the Senses. Conversely, a qwerty keyboard is probably useful for younger users. Remember, we all grew up in the era of Perkins braillers, so all--or at least most-- of us learned to write on a Perkins style keyboard first. I bet there are an awful lot of kids out there now who have never even seen a Perkins style keyboard, but have seen a PC. If I were Hims I'd put my money on the keyboard and not the screen. Just my
$.02.
Cheers,
Donna

-----Original Message-----
From: erik burggraaf [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Tuesday, May 19, 2009 10:10 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [GWN] qwerty keyboard

Well that's just a bit sad. I know on the face of it the screen might
seem like a fluffy feature, but people can use it in classroom
situations or as a comunication aid for deaf blind.  It also sets the
sense appart.  There are lots of good reasons to like the sense, but
no other note taker device in it's class has a screen.  Where-as evry
other one has a model that has built in qwerty keyboard.  That's
really the only good reason I can think of for building the unit, and
I'm told by all the business consultants I've ever listened to that
it's dangerous to follow the pack.

Don't forget that the sense is a relatively new product.  Back when
the blt and the braille note were being developed you couldn't get
portable keyboards of any stripe.  Now of course they abound.  You
couldn't get wireless devices back then either, and of course now they
are evrywhere.

Best,

erik burggraaf
A+ sertified technician and user support consultant.
Phone: 888-255-5194
Email: [email protected]

On 18-May-09, at 4:07 PM, Stacey Robinson wrote:

Eric,
I think I read on this list that there won't be a display on the
units with qwerty keyboard.

Have a blessed day,
Stacey Robinson and GEB dog Chesley
Eagleville, Tennessee.
[email protected]
You can also write me at
[email protected]

Check out my website and blog at
www.samobile.net/users/staceylr

----- Original Message ----- From: "erik burggraaf" <e...@erik-
burggraaf.com

To: <[email protected]>
Sent: Sunday, May 17, 2009 8:58 PM
Subject: Re: [GWN] qwerty keyboard


Hi Chris,  It'll be interesting to see, because the sense is a bit
narrower than the braille note if memory serves correctly.  It
also  needs to devote a little rectangle of space on the topface to
the  display screen.  I'm not saying it's impossible, just that it
will be  interesting to see how they work it out.

Best,


erik burggraaf
A+ sertified technician and user support consultant.
Phone: 888-255-5194
Email: [email protected]

On 17-May-09, at 11:16 AM, Chris G wrote:

Hi,

I don't know about the qwerty sense product, but the form factor
of  the
BrailleNote QT and BrailleNote BT is exactly the same.

Perhaps Raul can comment.

Chris



On Wed, 13 May 2009 08:08:46 -0400
erik burggraaf <[email protected]> wrote:

Hi Sharen,  I recomend finding yourself something like the
stowaway
bluetooth keybord at a sell phone accessory place or on Ebay.

For myself, I am a bit dubious about the idea of a qwerty sense
because of the extra space it will take.  I'd really like to see
them
put the flash drives on top of one another instead of beside,
shrink
the keys down to about a quarter the size, cut the entire unit
in  half
length wise, and thin it out a bit.  All of which would make it
smaller rather than bigger.  Then they could include the bt
keybord  as
an accessory, optional or not.

Best,
erik burggraaf
A+ sertified technician and user support consultant.
Phone: 888-255-5194
Email: [email protected]

On 12-May-09, at 2:54 PM, Sharon Hamm wrote:

 Does anyone know when the qwerty version of the braillesense
will be coming out? Will you be able to trade the old
braillesense
in for it?
Sharon





__________ Information from ESET Smart Security, version of virus
signature database 4080 (20090515) __________

The message was checked by ESET Smart Security.

http://www.eset.com



--
The home of the Mystic Place blog and podcast.
www.mysticplace.info
RSS: feeds.feedburner.com/mysticplacebp




No virus found in this incoming message.
Checked by AVG - www.avg.com
Version: 8.5.339 / Virus Database: 270.12.34/2121 - Release Date:
05/19/09 06:21:00


Reply via email to