Some thoughts: 1) The UN and every other nation, to one extent or another, employs mercenaries. If we define a mercenary as a soldier who works for pay, then pretty much every army fits that bill. Try to not pay your first world army for any length of time and see just how well that goes over...
2) The UN has studied the use of PMCs and some advocates have suggested the use of PMCs. One of the big problem in UN deployments is national governments imposing secondary ROEs and terms-of-use restrictions. Another one is nations having an election and a sudden change in policy, possibly resulting in pulling out their troops. This makes the idea of a unit of professionals, beholden only to their paymaster (conjecturally the UN), potentially a more stable and effective way to do many of the sorts of stabilization missions the UN may wish to do. (Note: I'm totally ignoring the obvious issue of corruption and incompetence.) 3) The UN in our world draws from nations around the globe. But it suffers from this in terms of interoperability, communication, mutual support - all of which aren't anywhere near what you'd like. Even competent forces that don't work together all that often may not do such a good job. And many UN missions are not exactly what conventional warfighters train for. So to be a good UN soldier, you may have to retrain into new processes (and then train back to return to a more conventional warfighting role). 4) The UN as it stands today has no tax base and no population to draw soldiers from. It cannot recruit from any nation (because it has no tax base and it would have to ask permission anyway). This point is short, but it means the UN in the GZGverse could not exist with this same support mechanism. That's a profound truth. 5) The UN often goes into places (like many internationalist efforts) and tries to do some good and does a bad job of it (troops that don't speak the language, cultural clashes, poorly trained troops in some cases) and/or leaves too soon. This is one of the challenges of only being able to mount missions if and when member countries allow it and with whatever resources they give you when you show up cap in hand. 6) The UN in the GZGverse actually has enough capability to enforce its will upon uber-powers (bigger than hyper) like the ESU and NAC. Do the demographics for these states, even with pessimistic assumptions, and you get *huge* tax bases and manpower bases. They've got a lot of real estate to protect, but their amount of political and economic influence would be quite terrifying. And yet the UNSC gets them to play ball in the Core and at Homeworld. Mostly. The UNSC also has a cool fleet of (presumably expensive) ships of its own design with crews that one presumes, in a universe of regular large scale conflict, actually get something accomplished, so I can't see them being loyal to various nations whose factional loyalties change regularly. Studying what the UN can do in the GZGverse tells me several things: 1) It has its own tax base. It probably is not as big as the ESU or NAC, but it has its own tax base. Probably it owns scientific patents, it gets some funding from the member nations, and it probably has acquired some other funding methods like (just making these up) a tax on each colonist outbound from the core or a tax on each FTL drive or whatever. But ultimately, it needs a revenue source sufficient to give it credibility, make it a professional force, remove the worst risks of corruption (otherwise this guts the other two previous aspects mentioned), and sufficient to pay for large ships and well armoured Marines, even if they are fewer in number than the forces of the larger nations. It is an entity in its own right with its own sources of cash and can't be directly hobbled by any one member nation. 2) It has its own manpower base. Tax base must mean a manpower base. I assume it actually does recruit from veterans of other national fleets and armies. It may also have basically opened UN citizenship to a lot of the smaller spots on the world (small island nations, and so on) to drum up a base population - if sea levels rise, maybe the UN helped them get setup off world and thus gets something which evolves into its own population base. I assume UN manpower base is not as large as its tax/financial base (which could be driven largely by scientific patents), but it has to be enough to provide some decent number of recruits for a small UNSC Marine force and a UNSC Navy. Sure, UN missions still need national forces in support. Big fleets will have some UNSC ships and a bunch of national ones. But the national ones will always operate under double ROE and with possibly differing agendas, so the UN has its own smaller navy and ground forces, enough to ensure that the NAC or ESU not supporting a particular action will still let the UN's agenda go forward. I think the UN of the GZGverse has the equivalent financial base of a second tier power. I think it has the technological base of a first tier power and the population base of a lower second or upper third tier power. This lets it do the kind of things the canon history shows it doing. It also means that the UNSC still needs the support from some of the other major players to get very large scale stuff done. The UNSC won't be investing planets on its own. It won't be running huge spaceborne campaigns by itself. But it has enough strength, professionalism, income and manpower to be a credible coordinating authority and to not be as corrupt as the current day version. I'm working backwards from miniatures and from canon history and trying to provide an understanding of the UN that justifies the things they've accomplished and the miniatures produced. The UN of today would not work in the era of large scale bloc-type conflicts across space and with the feeble budgets of today and the corruption and ineffectiveness. Since this is not what canon gives us, we must imagine some scenario that makes canon possible and it is a fairly different flavour of UN that this suggests. And mercenaries figure in this if the UN runs the Bonding Authority. They insure factions stick to the Mercenary Charter (and so do PMCs), they get a cut of every transaction, and they have available small groups of professional soldiers to use to supplement their own limited forces when crises arise and where member nation support is either slow to rally or politically problematic. The UN would use mercenaries as stiffeners and fire-brigades, whereas most of the other powers would use them to give isolation from actions (proxies) and to not require the nation to deploy its troops into whatever situation or conflict. TomB -- http://ante-aurorum-tenebrae.blogspot.com/ http://www.stargrunt.ca "He that would make his own liberty secure must guard even his enemy from oppression; for if he violates this duty he establishes a precedent that will reach to himself." -- Thomas Paine "When men yield up the privilege of thinking, the last shadow of liberty quits the horizon." -- Thomas Paine --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Ground Zero Games" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/gzg-group?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
_______________________________________________ Gzg-l mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://vermouth.csua.berkeley.edu:1337/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/gzg-l
