I've read the reply posts so far, and I can't help but let my mind drift to the hidden core question...
"Should we have lost in Vietnam?" [email protected] "Always strive to be a good person. If you can't do that, at least strive to be someone other than an asshole." -----Original Message----- From: John Atkinson Sent: Saturday, December 13, 2008 11:43 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Re: [GZG] Question: small-arms tech and troop quality.... On Sat, Dec 13, 2008 at 9:52 AM, Ground Zero Games <[email protected]> wrote: > Here's a deliberately vague and provocative question to get a > stimulated debate going...... <GRIN!!> > > "Is one super-trained elite special forces soldier with the best > cutting-edge high-tech weapon worth 25 untrained farmers with > shotguns?" Maybe. More importantly, 8-12 super-trained elite special forces soldiers with the best cutting-edge high-tech weapons are worth 250 or more untrained farmers with shotguns. A lot of the advantages of training and discipline come into play with unit cohesion, morale, and effective teamwork. The horde of untrained folks are going to run away a lot sooner if they run into problems, and aren't going to be able to use their numbers to good advantage, and may even inflict casualties on each other by accident. > OK, now to put it a little bit into context..... > > If we have a (game) situation where there are five levels of troop > quality from 1 = Untrained up to 5 = Elite, and similarly five bands > of "tech level" where 1 = primitive firearms (that's "primitive" in > the SF sense, eg: early to mid 20th century stuff, bolt-action rifles > and such) and 5 = highly advanced weapons (plasma/fusion rifles), > then is it in any way reasonable to calculate effective firepower by > a simple multiplication of the two factors? No. A lot depends on factors beyond the weapons themselves. Body armor and sensors play into the question as well. For instance, at night the best weapons in the world don't help without night vision technology, and farmers with bolt-action rifles and night vision would lunch on anyone without night vision. Further, if the high-tech troops are armored in, say, Traveller-type battledress, the low-tech fighters literally cannot penetrate and hence can only injure the high-tech troops with heavy crew-served weapons. So masses of riflemen become irrelevant to firepower calculations and useful only to delay and harass and hide the heavy machine guns and antitank rifles that can actually kill the battledress. On the other hand, if no one is wearing armor, then the tech levels of the weapons become much less relevant and the training of the troops become paramount. M-14s vs. Super-tech gauss rifles is small enough of a difference that it almost gets lost in the noise compared to troop quality, presuming that the gauss rifle is simply an assault rifle with light-weight ammunition, high muzzle velocity (and hence superior armor penetration) and somewhat higher rate of fire--though if it gets too high the benefit is lost to a shoulder-fired weapon without a built in fire control computer and stabilization system. > will matter a lot. All I'm talking about is the ability to place an > effective weight of fire down on a target area, at whatever we decide > to be the effective combat range for a given type of weapon. When it comes to that, I tend to feel that crew-served weapons are as important or more so than the rifles in question. Good machine guns can make up for inferior rifles if you have enough of them. While the Germans had inferior rifles to the US troops in WWII, the fact that they had a superb and technologically superior machine gun which was integrated into every single infantry squad more than made up for that. And the superior US combined arms and fire support trumped the firepower of German squads in any case anyway. :) I have deliberately ignored the question of plasma/fusion rifles, as it all depends on how one wishes to treat them in game mechanical terms. The precise characteristics of the weapon must be more concrete to determine the effects of the weapon on tactics. John -- "Thousands of Sarmatians, Thousands of Franks, we've slain them again and again. We're looking for thousands of Persians." --Vita Aureliani _______________________________________________ Gzg-l mailing list [email protected] http://vermouth.csua.berkeley.edu:1337/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/gzg-l _______________________________________________ Gzg-l mailing list [email protected] http://vermouth.csua.berkeley.edu:1337/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/gzg-l --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Ground Zero Games" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/gzg-group?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
