Jon, Your new formulation seems more focused and more easily thought upon.
It seems to me that the contrast between poorer and better troops is, given the same tech is: - somewhat improved effective range for better troops - better troops zero their sights, shoot enough to have a good feel for windage, and are more calm and focused doing their job - improved efficacy at all ranges when compared to their poorer counterparts. Better concentration, better use of bursts, a sense of timing, coordination of fires, etc ROF, as such, isn't the determiner. As the resident ginger beer pointed out, good troops don't use full auto much. Aimed shots, with rifle at shoulder, using sights, vs. spray and pray. Even given the same guns, I'd expect slightly better effective ranges and better effectiveness at all ranges. SG2 captured this with quality based range bands and quality in the attack calculation, although the variability of polyhedral dice sometimes make that hard to see. So I would say good troops should provide an additional firepower factor at any range and should perhaps have slightly longer maximum effective range. (Note, I'm talking practical range, not how far a bullet could actually travel) Comparing troops of equal quality using weapons of differing qualities, I would expect that better weapons (of any given sort, say comparing an advanced rifle with a basic one) would: - potentially add to effective range (better aerodynamics of the round, better sights, better recoil management) - add to accuracy at most or all ranges (similar reasons) - deliver burst increasing hit percentages - have better penetration or tissue damage So, you can then examine your initial suggestion of: Aggregate FP = Troop Q x Weap TL (rating 1-5 for each) If you aren't rolling FMAesque dice, and just using this rating, then a Troop of Q2 can effectively *be* 2x as good as a Troop from Q1. Same with tech. If, OTOH, you are using SG style dice, Green D6 vs. Regular D8 isn't a 2x relationship... I'd have to get Beth or OA to speak to the value, but my guess is that's about a 25% increase. Ditto the way weapon FP/accuracy dice go. Even if I'm a better gun (one die type up), it won't be a 2x relationship. So it sort of depends on the underlying rules mechanics. The balance would be different depending on the backing rules. But even then, I don't totally like that formula. If we take a test case: TL1 Q1: Rabble with smoothbore muskets TL4 Q4: Experienced veterans with high tech advanced combat rifles Is the ratio 16 to 1? I don't think practically that your described tech spread matches with a xN relationship. TL1 and TL5 are closer than 5x and probably so is troop quality. If you traded weapons: TL1 Q4: Veteran Gaurds with smoothbore muskets TL4 Q1: Untrained rabble with high tech ACRs The suggestion here would be that the result is equal. I don't think so. All the expertise in the world won't overcome the basic ballistics and ROF of the smoothbore. Idiots may be using the ACRs, but some of the rounds are likely to find their mark and they shoot a lot more a lot faster and to better range even in the hands of clowns. Let us also consider one of the ginger beer's points: Poor troops don't act with coordination or efficacy and lack espirit de corps or morale to keep to the fight. This does manifest itself, even in the firepower field. But John rightly points out a certain scale is needed to reap the teamwork and coordination benefits. And most of these aspects show up in other regards. I have not found math that works that doesn't cause an aneurysm in test subjects or epileptic seizures when contemplating edge cases.... Every simple formula I tried leads to a bucket full of fail..... ------------------------ SG2 Rules of Thumb: My experience in SG2 has been that, assuming terrain and ROE allows leveraging of quality advantages: - Veterans tend to be worth 25-33% more than regulars, but that factors in their better range bands and better QD for shooting (and possibly their better QD for comm checks, reaction tests, etc) - Elite tend to be worth 50% more than regulars. You start to hit issues with numbers of activations and number of casualties you can take here. Smaller Elite forces become more subject to randomness of dice than larger (more regression to the mean) forces of rabble. - Greens, including panic and special morale failings, are worth about 50% of regulars - Untrained troops might be worth 20-25% of regulars, but they might never get in range if the regs move and shoot. I'd guess 20% might be fair if you don't forget to apply the correct morale and panic rules. SG2 uses the polyhydrals and that means a D8 isn't that much worse than a D10 (mean 4.5 vs. 5.5 and both have the dreaded 1). It does count, but it isn't doubling. And the D10 is inherently more unpredictable than the D4 which matters in some decisions. If you were to try to preserve the good sort of balance of potence that SG2 gives, you might find that 6-8 stands of untrained, poorly equipped colonists might be worth 1 stand of elite SF. Simlarly, about 3 stands of militia with slightly outdated tech might be worth 1 SF stand. You just can't pile up suppression heavily enough and fast enough as one SF stand to handle being hugely outnumbered. I think you'll find with a point system that the more you try to break it down, the more you'll have skewed results. Perhaps just rating a stand and giving a rough idea of what a stand should contain is the way to go. That's how I eyeball SG2 clashes, realizing that you also want to keep within about 25% in number of activations in most cases for the most fun games. I also know that more than 3 FP dice per stand starts to really bend the ruleset in unpleasant ways. SF in SG2 play much like I'd expect them to in the real world - they can hit waaay hard and move fast and shrug off some damage, but once they get suppressed and pinned, they'd better bust out fast or the plebes will dogpile on them until they cannot activate to do much but remove suppression and they eventually start taking wounds and dying. They're brittle - if they can move and shoot, they are very potent and can defeat-in-detail lower quality units. When the higher quality units get pinned, they get hammered flat. That's hard to really put into points in a sane way because you have to play them a particular way to show their true capability - use them for a stand-up fight and you'll lose them fast. Untrained Yellows, by en large, fail to score hits, fail to penetrate with crappy weapons, have no range, and panic or run away at first chance - much like the real world. This works well but is very contingent on panic and morale and motivation rules being applied. TomB -- http://ante-aurorum-tenebrae.blogspot.com/ http://www.stargrunt.ca "He that would make his own liberty secure must guard even his enemy from oppression; for if he violates this duty he establishes a precedent that will reach to himself." -- Thomas Paine "When men yield up the privilege of thinking, the last shadow of liberty quits the horizon." -- Thomas Paine --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Ground Zero Games" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/gzg-group?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
_______________________________________________ Gzg-l mailing list [email protected] http://vermouth.csua.berkeley.edu:1337/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/gzg-l
