available = usage.getAvailable() - reserved
It is incorrect to minus reserved from usage.getAvailable() above since the
reserved space, which is the space reserved for non-hdfs used, may already be
occupied by some non-hdfs files but not necessarily empty space.
In pre HDFS-5215 calculation, the non-DFS used is like "unplanned non-DFS used"
while the "planned DFS used" is the reserved space.
Tsz-Wo
On Wednesday, April 13, 2016 2:35 PM, Brahma Reddy Battula
<brahmareddy.batt...@huawei.com> wrote:
Gentle Remainder!!
--Brahma Reddy Battula
From: Brahma Reddy Battula
Sent: 28 March 2016 12:26
To: hdfs-dev@hadoop.apache.org
Cc: 'aagar...@hortonworks.com'; 'cnaur...@hortonworks.com';
'vinayakum...@apache.org'
Subject: [HDFS-9038] Non-Dfs used Calculation
Hi All,
Chris Nauroth / Arpit / Vinay and me discussing this calculation.
There is a disagreement on the definition of non-DFS used space, because of
which Issue is not making progress.
Essentially, it's a question of whether this metric means "Raw Non-DFS Used" or
"Unplanned Non-DFS Used".
Here is the summary of the conversation, by Arpit.
The pre HDFS-5215 calculation had two bugs.
1. It incorrectly subtracted reserved space from the non-DFS used. (net
negative). Chris suggests this is not really an issue as non-DFS used should be
shown as zero unless it exceeds the DFS reserved value.
2. It used File#getUsableSpace to calculate the volume free space instead of
File#getFreeSpace. (net positive)
The net effect was that non-DFS used was displayed as zero unless the actual
non-DFS used exceeded DFS reserved - system reserved.
HDFS-5215 fixed the first issue and the value that is now erroneously counted
towards non-DFS used is in fact the system reserved 5%.
>From the testing it was found that, "Ext derivatives hold back 5% free space
>while XFS does not."
Proposed calculation to report the exact Non-DFS Usage:
non-DFS used = getCapacity() + reserved - getDfsUsed() - totalFreeSpace
= usage.getCapacity() - reserved + reserved - getDfsUsed() -
totalFreeSpace
= usage.getCapacity() - getDfsUsed() - totalFreeSpace
= File#getTotalSpace - getDfsUsed() - File#getFreeSpace
Chris Nauroth thinks we should subtract "dfs.datanode.du.reserved" for non-dfs
used because it allowed to monitor for unexpected non-zero non-DFS usage and
react.
Even Akira given "+0" on above calculation.
We would like take inputs from you to see some progress on the issue.
Please let me know your thoughts on this issue.
Thanks
--Brahma Reddy Battula
