I think this deserves some attention. More than just the question of JIRA vs GitHub Issues, I'm a little concerned that we completely changed the way we post code changes without a vote thread or even a discussion thread that had a clear outcome. The previous thread ([DISCUSS] Tips for improving productivity, workflow in the Hadoop project?) had many committers giving opinions on the matter, but it never came to conclusion and just sat there with no traffic for months. The way I read the previous thread was that committers were proposing that we clean out stale PRs, not that we turn off JIRA patches/Precommit builds.
I'm not necessarily saying that we should go with patches vs GitHub PRs, but I'm concerned that the decision was made without community support/consensus and without a vote thread (not sure if that's necessary for this type of change or not). Eric On Mon, Mar 28, 2022 at 1:18 PM Eric Badger <ebad...@yahooinc.com> wrote: > If we're not using patches on JIRA anymore, why are we using JIRA at all? > Why don't we just use GitHub Issues? Using JIRA to then redirect to GitHub > seems unintuitive and will fracture the information between two different > places. Do the conversations happen on JIRA or on a GitHub PR? Having > conversations on both is confusing and splitting information. I would > rather use JIRA with patches or GitHub Issues with PRs. I think anything in > between splits information and makes it hard to find. > > Eric > > On Sun, Mar 27, 2022 at 1:25 PM Akira Ajisaka <aajis...@apache.org> wrote: > >> Dear Hadoop developers, >> >> I've disabled the Precommit-(HADOOP|HDFS|MAPREDUCE|YARN)-Build jobs. >> If you attach a patch to a JIRA issue, the Jenkins precommit job won't >> run. >> Please use GitHub PR for code review. >> >> Background: >> - >> https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/HADOOP-17798__;!!Op6eflyXZCqGR5I!Swsnm6LmEvbzZPTXn9xJuCkXtLBzb7zHkK2P_Cw-dH5K2IwoSEzQBC2oQG0D$ >> - >> https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://lists.apache.org/thread/6g3n4wo3b3tpq2qxyyth3y8m9z4mcj8p__;!!Op6eflyXZCqGR5I!Swsnm6LmEvbzZPTXn9xJuCkXtLBzb7zHkK2P_Cw-dH5K2IwoSEzQBHA0JrdK$ >> >> Thanks and regards, >> Akira >> >
