Hello everybody!

I appreciate your help and responses.

Greg,

I've been checking histograms with CANON Digital Photo Professional. I was
checking L channel, I guess I need to make sure RGB values are below 200 as
well. Are there any suggestions on this issue?

Martin,

That is a very interesting suggestion! I guess I can see the difference
between the measurements of two light sources.

>> ..the photopic sensitivity curve V(lambda) currently used is incorrect.
It underestimates blue wavelengths quite a bit.
>> You should really use a CCD camera with a photopic filter to get better
values..

You say that V(lambda) underestimates the values. But doesn't CCD camera's
photopic filter have the same response curve? So, it would have the same
mistake.

Lars,

>> Did you derive the response curve of your camera using another setup
(not the directly visible LED) and reuse that camera response later on your LED
captures? Or do you take the camera response from the same set of images
(showing the LED in an otherwise dark room) that you are going to assemble
into a HDR?

I've tried two approaches. The first one is to derive the response curve
from the scene with very dark and bright areas with smooth gradients
and neutral colors. Then fuse them to obtain RC. And then I've used it in
photosphere for subsequent HDRIs. And the second one is to fuse raw images
with Greg's script raw2hdr, where you don't have to have response curve.
Greg: "The raw2hdr script doesn't need to derive a response curve, since
the sensor data is linear.  Instead, it creates an output from dcraw that
follows a 2.0 gamma and creates an artificial response curve of x^2 to
decode it.  This reduces quantization errors from the 8-bit intermediate
images". And then I can analyse my hdr image in Photosphere.

-- 
Thank you,
*Yulia Tyukhova*
*
*
Fulbright Scholar, "Intern LC"
Architectural Engineering Graduate Student, UNL-Omaha, NE, USA
B.E. and M.E. in Lighting Engineering (MPEI), Moscow, Russia
[email protected]
[email protected]
+1 (402) 996 0910
PKI 247
_______________________________________________
HDRI mailing list
[email protected]
http://www.radiance-online.org/mailman/listinfo/hdri

Reply via email to