Daniel, you come closest to the voice of reason in this over-long thread. 

Speaking of "ideal tubes," as we know:
1) A half closed cylinder resonates at odd harmonics, e.g. C, the G an octave 
and a half higher, E, Bb-... Not very useful. Clarinets and hosaphones are 
cylindrical.
2) A half closed conical tube resonates at the harmonic series. S***phones are 
mostly conical. So much for theory.
3) Flaring tubes resonate at however you flare them.

Now, the French horn has conical, cylindrical, and flaring sections and is not 
ideal. The fact that it resonates at approximately the harmonic series is a 
tribute to the designer and builder, not physics.

So why are we arguing over whether the 8th "harmonic" is in tune or not?

Herb Foster




________________________________
From: Daniel Canarutto <[email protected]>
To: The Horn List <[email protected]>
Sent: Mon, November 23, 2009 4:53:16 AM
Subject: Re: [Hornlist] tuning a Conn 8D / I'll stick to Physics regarding 
intonation

On 22Nov 2009, at 21:37 , [email protected] wrote:

> ...
>
> Where we disagree is the last statement. I think that an  
> understanding  of
> any sciences will help you in all aspects of life including a  
> concert or a
> symphony. I'm a scientific mind and to me knowledge of any sort is  
> always
> welcome and is always handy.

William, I'm no expert in acoustics matters, but I've been teaching  
University courses in mathematics and physics for (gasp!) nearly 30  
years by now, and I have published a number of papers in international  
scientific journals; I'm saying this just to support the notion that I  
have some idea of what science and physics is about. From your posts I  
got the impression that your ideas on this subject are rather naive (I  
admit I don't know your background). Of course the physics and  
mathematics of harmonic analysis is solid, but we should never forget  
that in physics we are always reasoning in terms of "mathematical  
models" (I prefer this term to "theory"). ANY mathematical model is a  
simplified description of the real physics, and a more precise  
description requires a more complex model: you choose the level of  
complexity according to your needs of accuracy, but NEVER attain a  
COMPLETE description.

Speaking of horns, there are many reasons (as others have noted) why  
it's non sufficient, under many respects, to treat a horn as an ideal  
tube of a given length. Just to add a further observation, a curved  
tube actually doesn't have a uniquely, precisely defined length (the  
wave traveling near the interior of a curve has a shorter way to go;  
this point was already once stressed by prof.Holmes-Cabbage).

I am also dubious that mathematics could really help me in practical  
performance.

All the best,
Daniel
_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/herb_foster%40yahoo.com



      
_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org

Reply via email to