There are many 3rd finger notes as you've explained. There's also the 1 to 2 combinations as well. I have tried playing it in an A/E horn and I didn't like it because I preferred a shorter horn. I thought I had explained that? But it is strange how some people on the list claim knowledge of math and science is useless for Horn playing. If math is so useless then how do they count. If science is so useless you might as well be guessing what you're doing in terms of intonation and acoustics. Science is the best tool we have right now to objectively find the truth. The proof is in the pudding. We didn't land on the moon by performing Schumann. Am I completely right 100% of the time? No. There were a few things about acoustics I wasn't aware of. However nothing that the experts in this field have said have detracted from my tuning method either. I'm also not the only person who uses this method either. You may think understanding more about how the world works is useless - but I don't. And as for civilization - it counts on this knowledge. The real world isn't going to progress with superstition/tradition/magic. It is only going to improve/progress with rational/logical discourse. This is why music/arts (while important to some degree) are always going to be secondary to the fundamentals.
After all, how are you going to paint/decorate a house if you haven't even built it? Again, your way works for you. My way works for me. That's that. -William In a message dated 11/28/2009 3:18:49 P.M. Eastern Standard Time, [email protected] writes: You are very funny indeed. How many pitches require the use of the third finger ?? g# on the F-side, c# on the Bb-side. That many ?? Well, if you start talking about the octave below the staff, if playing the low notes from f# down to low c, you must use the third finger, but it does sound very dull and do not respond at the point, so you switch better to the Bb-side, involving the third finger for the again just for the c#. Are that many ? And is this a result of a weaker finger action with the third ? No, by no means. Simply, it is not necessary to use a 23 combination for other notes nor do you need the third finger alone use, except if for an held "a" (written), which is alone & special audible. So your arguments about the weak action fail completely, no matter from which side you might look. If the third finger action is not required much, where is the problem, leading to a complete change when using A/E horn ? Does your broad knowledge of molecules & galactic interactions or chemistry (assumption) help you for playing the horn ? I doubt that strongly. And, you perhaps never (assumption, but I am quite sure) tried my way, but I was educated to use the single E-horn (Viennese F Horn with the shorter crook for E) & the single Bb (Viennese Horn with the stick only). But the result did not please me (ear-lip-automatic confusion, tone quality), so I know what you were speaking about. The use of these converted horns is(was) part of the education in Vienna. ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ +++++ Am 28.11.2009 um 20:33 schrieb [email protected]: > > Funny how you mention though that the E fingerings aren't a problem, then > when I bring in the 3rd finger issue the goalposts switch to "well you don't > use it that often anyway!". > > Seems to me you're doing everything in your power to ignore using it as > well - we just have two different approaches. > > If it works for both of us - why should there be any argument? > > -William > _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/valkhorn%40aol.com _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org
