On Jul 12, 2010, at 4:06 PM, [email protected] wrote:

> From: "[email protected]" <[email protected]>
> To: [email protected]
> Sent: Mon, July 12, 2010 12:56:00 PM
> Subject: Re: [Hornlist] About those brass playing robots...
>
>
> One of the smartest people I've ever met asked us once in an  
> orchestration class
> what music was. The correct definition is 'organized sound'. That's  
> it.

Well thank goodness for one of the smartest people you now. Where  
would be without him. Not doing this, i guess. After all your ranting  
about being scientific you give us this?

> Your
> interpretation, your emotion, your 'feelings' or 'gut' or whatever  
> is not part
> of that definition.

This is like saying that life is just about money, because it can be  
quantified, it can get you any feeling you want and can make your life  
more healthy. Epic fail, if that is what you were taught.

> A lot of music was composed programatically.

true! And that music has a story, or a picture, or an emotion or  
whatever.

> Some was
> composed out of form only.

Not so true. Forms arose from song and expressions of the day. Here is  
where you start to stray from reality. Just because a piece has a  
'form' doesn't mean it was composed 'out of a form' with no expression  
or feeling. I shouldn't have to tell you this. This is obvious to  
anyone. I suppose Beethoven would agree with you , though. Just kidding.

> Why should we be forced to attach emotions to music
> at all when some music was not composed to trigger a response from  
> the audience
> at all.

Oh boy, now you assume that music WASN'T designed to evoke emotions,  
when many composers said so themselves. really, you have gone over the  
edge now. By the way, no one is forcing anyone a to attach emotions to  
anything. If you want to believe that little dots on a page represent  
all the depth of a composer's thoughts, then i have several things i  
would like to sell you. Its like saying a book is all that went on in  
an author's mind when she was writing it.
Do the words "performance practice" mean anything to you? Do you  
believe that Mozart wrote everything in his scores that we need to  
know from our study of music? Do you think that because Mozart wrote  
in obvious forms with no programatic titles that he expressed nothing  
beyond the written notes. How about Bach? How about ANY composer? Come  
on, give it up. Stop the madness.
>
>
> You can have an emotional response. You may not have one. That's  
> your call.
> However, when you start bridging into the realm of 'spiritualism' in  
> music then
> you're getting into a realm that, again, is indistinguishable from  
> make-believe.

This is true. Some people have more emotional responses than others.  
Whew, glad we got that straight. Otherwise, another fail. Does the  
word Scientology mean anything to you?
>
> In other words (and I've said this how many times now?) you can have  
> that
> feeling all you want, but it does no good to teach it because you  
> can't teach
> it, and it does no good to really progress playing and progress  
> music because
> you might as well be talking about magic purple monkeys or the ether  
> theory or
> something.

OK, now we get to the heart of this. Yes you can teach it. I do it  
every day. All great teachers can do it. Kids can figure it out on  
their own with a little help. it is NOT brain surgery. I'm sorry that  
you didn't get the kind of instruction or exposure to the kind of  
musicians and musical experiences that would make you have this  
ridiculous position. I guess you have never walked down a street and  
heard some people singing or just someone whistling a tune, because  
that is where it all started. Singing. Expression. Human communication  
of emotion.

We ALL play because we LOVE music. We may get off track at times and  
just become robots and 'bean counters," but we all LOVE music. If you  
don't, then I can understand why you write these kinds of things and i  
am through with you.

I am sure you would be glad to know that the great Marcel Tabuteau  
assigned numbers to phrasing and dynamics when he taught, especially  
in his later years when he became more interested in passing on his  
teachings. These numbers, however, were relative, not absolute, and  
they were only a guideline , used to increase the attention of  
students to detail that T was trying to teach. I use a modified method  
like this myself. But it is shorthand, not a treatise. Tabuteau was  
considered on of the most expressive players and successful teachers  
in history.
>
> If you are able to analyze and figure out what Perlman or Domingo or  
> even Ravi
> Shankar was doing then you are able to learn it yourself, you become  
> able to
> teach it, and more people can figure out how to be just as great.  
> They are
> human, too. What they are doing is nothing magical. They aren't  
> invoking Thor
> and Loki and an army of Frost Giants. They aren't using a magic  
> ring. They don't
> have a spear and magic helmet.

Wow, now you actually say something true. Is this what you were trying  
to say al along?  It all depends on how you analyze it, though. I  
would be interested to know how you plan to do that, especially with  
your biases against emotion and expression. Maybe you should get back  
to us when you have a plan.

The  good news is that we already have ways to pass on this  
information to students who have the interest to delve into it. We  
could use more people passing the info along. That is why i am writing  
my book and DVD set. that is why i teach, and i am sure i speak for  
many many people on these forums.
>
>
> I advocate figuring it out. Some advocate a blank stare.

Blank stare is your prejudice. Just like your last thread. I advocate  
studying music and music history, listening to great performances,  
trying to get what the composer was doing, learning about inner beat  
phrasing so YOU can do it, and when you have an idea of what you want  
to express, you carefully calculate and practice how you are going to  
do it, because if you don't, you run the risk of not letting everyone  
else know what you are thinking and feeling. People aren't mind  
readers, and I do object to people who say they are expressive when  
they are only 'going with the flow' and just hoping others will 'get  
it.'

Here is a better topic. How many of you out there agree with what I  
have said in this last paragraph? Is real expression, or shall we say  
effective expression just letting the feelings go while you play or is  
it planned so others can share in your experience? I know it isn't  
just one or the other, But i say it is heavily weighted in terms of  
planned expression that can be taught and is taught every day.
>
> -William

Cheers,
Wendell
For info about my book, DVDs, and live video chat horn lessons, see my  
web site at www.wendellworld.com









_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org

Reply via email to