Ralph R. Hall
[email protected]
Ralph R. Hall
http://www.brasshausmusic.com

I was determined to stay out of this because William and I have  
crossed (verbal) swords before. And I sympathise if he is  being  
excised from the list because, at the very least, his contributions  
generate counter contributions. If we all agreed, and just stuck to  
horn topics, it would be the most boring list imaginable - maybe it is  
anyway!

All I would like to say is that I recently visited Belgium and the WW  
1 cemeteries therein. There was a point to this because my wife's  
great uncle died, aged 20, at Ypres. My eldest son is an amateur  
military historian as well as a professional tubist and the three of  
us set off to find the appropriate grave. So that I don't stray too  
far off musical topics, I won't deal with the emotions generated here  
but go forward to a visit later on the same day to the ceremony at the  
Menin Gate in Ypres.

For those who don't know, the Last Post is sounded here at 20.00 hrs  
each day in honour of those who died in the vicinity. Of course over  
time this has been expanded in hearts and minds to include all who  
died in this particular conflict. My point is that, on this specific  
evening, there was a wreath laying ceremony and a military presence,  
including a march to the memorial and away at the conclusion. All of  
this was performed by the local Fire Service Band. This sort of outfit  
is usually the source of 'Hulotesque' comedy. Now I'm a cynical  
professional and I've played in the best concert halls in the world  
but I was deeply moved by the understated, heartfelt contribution that  
this band made. They played well in tune, with a great range of  
dynamics, under a a very efficient conductor and there was something  
emotional and intangible in the air which they conveyed through their  
music. There was a respectful silence from the crowd, including many  
schoolkids, and looking around there were many, of all ages, with  
watery eyes.

All I'm going to say is this: even if this sort of response is  
measurable and quantifiable, is it necessarily productive to go down  
this route and if it is, would it then diminish our reactions?

Ralph R. Hall








_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org

Reply via email to