Hi, As more and more Hotties use now some fancy smartphones for OSM field survey instead of classic GPS devices like Garmin eTrex, but without the matter having never been discussed (if I am not wrong), I had the idea to create a GoogleDocs spreadsheet<https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AvC6dUAEbjPidGdpN1JjRGFKdExKMHY2YW9FU2gteWc#gid=0>to get some feed-backs. Kate and Nicolas already had a look on it but feel free to add some extra fields if it seems necessary.
Through this, we might identify good models for different kinds of use, that are not only related to technical aspects. As an example, in some countries, the main feature a smartphone must have is to be absolutely low profile. Beyond this, comes the editing-OSM-on-field issue: more and more solutions appear allowing to make surveys in electronic forms (web connected or synchronized when back to the office). As an example, a online forum about ICT in agriculture <http://www.ictinagriculture.org/ictinag/node/133> will occur soon. Even more related to our scope, this new initiave inter agencies/NGOs : http://humanitarian-nomad.org/ I don't mean electronic forms should necessarily replace paper forms + maps surveys: for technical, cultural, practical, etc. reasons, they are sometimes the best solution anyway. But for some programs have intrinsic features or demands (time, education level or number of people implied) that make this kind of methodologies necessary. Existing open-source OSM applications are far to offer even the basic Potlatch or JOSM functions. Vespucci is currently being improved: do the dev people think it will reach a state that would cover field survey needs in humanitarian contexts (what implies, at least, user-defined presets) ? Thoughts ? Sincerely, Severin
_______________________________________________ HOT mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/hot
