-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1 Hi, I had an argument with him too via PM and I kinda ticked a bit.. Felt a bit strange getting a lesson from someone mapping for 3 months and adding all in all 9000 nodes and having added about 100.000 in Nepal this year myself. Invalidating tasks completed by maning added some flavour to that one too.. :D He wants all buildings to be mapped. Even those in landuse=residential.
It feels like a waste of time, but the instructions are a bit ambiguous so technically he is not wrong! I can understand, that completing and validating a task should be the point in wich everything needed is mapped - #1018 is marked as STEP 2. So we are adding more details.. I am not sure what to do, but I pointed out to him, that his attitude might discourage some mappers (as it did to me at first (only a bit :D)). greetings from germany ngt P.S. at the moment I try to watch the activities and (re-)validate especially the ones done by beginners. In the comments there has to be a kind and more exhausting text on what to do, point out learnosm and be particular, what should be done different or be better. Try to avoid saying what is bad ;) Am 30.04.2015 um 16:51 schrieb Kretzer: > Makes sense to me ... > > In task #1018 there seems to be a user with little experience and lots of confidence invalidating dozens of tiles, arguing that "every individual structure needs to be traced". > The person even entered in a kind if edit war with maning. I really feel this is a waste of precious time. > > In this tasks there are very specific instructions on how to validate (which is a very good idea!). > They do clearly say that the major highways need to be there, not all the highways. > > I guess the goal is to get the relevant structures as quickly as possible. That kind of nitpicking seems to be just slowing the job. > > > Gesendet mit der GMX iPhone AppIFFK > > Am 30.04.15 um 15:49 schrieb Pierre GIRAUD > >> Hi all, >> >> I wasn't able to read all the email I got for the last 3 days, and >> there's a ton of those. >> >> However, I've seen a lot of people complaining about beginner mappers >> validating tasks even if they're not experienced enough to do so. >> Before we find a way to avoid this with additions to the tasking >> manager, I think there may be a workaround. >> >> What about making the (100% done) projects in a private mode >> temporarily and give access to a limited list of users so that they >> can validate the done tasks. >> >> This could be used for this project for example: >> http://tasks.hotosm.org/project/1008 >> >> This would prevent beginners to come to this project, wonder what to >> do and then validate tasks even if they don't know what they're doing. >> >> My 2 cents. >> >> Pierre >> >> -- >> ------------------------------------------------------------- >> | Pierre GIRAUD >> ------------------------------------------------------------- >> >> _______________________________________________ >> HOT mailing list >> HOT@openstreetmap.org >> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/hot > > _______________________________________________ > HOT mailing list > HOT@openstreetmap.org > https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/hot -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v2 iQIcBAEBAgAGBQJVQ6WqAAoJEMUCiYazPkhKgBcP/09YmyKW4fzupreyDvd7rp36 TZkG0G6gPPL3Wu+GmOpb+xznT04Mz4oBUAJDt6JvxlxK8y0QrcUdl1BY9xSzPK8N +DGZ8R6boogYNqcifhxpaBF7estqMq7PnfJxzppVwEygX0RxABSrolwm4ZXr7giK lbq1k3EczfEhXrvULTUNfT06fqnDksn62ga/SwYZGen0oMCsgrrQA7H6u8F5hMx2 yS73keCnxdZ9nbJlxOT4wPHK3DuAs7QWgsiBGAOQEu8ytA9gkAe4LRqJIpQWxVdR WAb9BfaQk1FQ393GvHfGP3K+fI25MfT5B0aLxAOQYDREUNjzbKlnxudTK++p5V3R sIpVCKpiP4jDhOPkMXPbSMETkBw55BXC913C2kvEq54RXgQMw7C+EbvIlxKeDJ2O frOIngIyT+eqNMUnQOe/Tuvn9h3R5Gcx/3qBIeZLI8vwslbIpDs9a2XKsbutp/xk tcsjpqEhyhmY0Fw81VM+H29PeemUzo1IHArYY2eyb4lBhWy8gw3qnvsTSvp9JSu1 I1fQLN0MQLihh3wC8A4uWKcRTRPf8MSmv72mQjg52gSE2HqAvmB0r3fQLaku5ZX4 KQE8PtKM5BEITd5Xw12yFQa27kwqL0pXqrDjiRzVRIBehp2Gq/1L7xia88Yi1A1B Rt+l7Mncu3UBWIjNRHtN =4rz2 -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- _______________________________________________ HOT mailing list HOT@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/hot
