"Alex V. Koval" <[email protected]> writes:

> At first BIG thanks for authors for creating such an excellent
> product!

i++ :-)

> I would like to share my 1-week experience here, because I think it is
> relevant for authours to understand what/how novices think. My
> impressions
> are fresh now, but the more I became used to, the less I will notice
> the small but important differencies which novice users need.

Nice to read, what other users are thinking, thx. I remember my first
week with i3. I never use a tiling WM before and know I can't without.

> Things I've noticed:
[...]
> 2) "Resize" section of default config file is too complicated. I've come
>     with much better solution for me, it is very easy to remember:
>
> # resize
> bindsym Mod4+Mod1+Left            resize shrink   right 3 px or 3 ppt
> bindsym Mod4+Mod1+Right           resize grow     right 3 px or 3 ppt
[...]

Same here. I skip entering resize mode, and do it directly like you.

> 4) [minor] I can not find the shortcut for Alt-Tab. Simple, this
> should be ability
>     to cycle windows on current desktop. Most of newcoming users would feel
>     bad without it.

I use Alt-Tab in this way and I like it.

  ## switching workspace
  bindsym Mod1+Tab workspace back_and_forth

But I agree, sometimes it would be nice to switch between the last two
windows.

> 5) [minor] Floating mode for the whole desktop.

Nice to have, but I don't need it really.

> 6) *Always* pressing Modkey+H, Modkey+V before every next program open is
>     overkill. I think more smart would be to cycle this. Why? Because now 
> every
>     next window open always have bigger ratio X*Y where it is comfortable to
>     work
>     with apps in square. So, what I mean, exactly, I think it would be helpful
>     if:
>       6.1. Mod+enter - opens terminal on full screen
>       6.2. Mod+enter - opens terminal split vertically
>       6.3. Mod+enter (without Modkey+v) opens new terminal split horizontally
>
> etc... Because I always tend to do it this way. I don't see big necessity
> to open tall narrow terminals.
>
>     6.4. Next one should open horizontally.
>
> Looks like we come up to somehow called 'spiral' layout, but its
> smarter because
> when you switch to other window, it would continue splitting this way.

I wouldn't like it. I want *my* layout and *no* rule. ;-) I have no
problem with hitting §mod-v to put the third terminal under the second.
For more complex layouts shell scripts can do a good job.


Frank

Reply via email to