On 10.12.2010, at 22.06, Sascha Silbe wrote:
Actually it would be great if all the Journals on XO could be (by
default) open for reading (and commenting) by everyone in the
learning
community / local, near by XO users.
That would be the exact opposite of great and it's something Bitfrost
intends to protect against [1,2]. The Journal is called thus for a
reason: It records _everything_ the user did on the system (within
Sugar, that is) and not just school-related work. If Journal entries
are to be published, it needs to be on an opt-in basis, not opt-out.
From the pedagogical point of view I would set the "journals" to be
by default open and let the users to choose if they want some of their
work to stay private. The open journals with commenting would provide
student a better changes to reach their zone of proximal development (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zone_of_proximal_development
). Without visibility of the activities with the Sugar, teachers (or
who ever is more skillful / knowledgeable) can not help their pupils.
Also, if the pupils can not follow the work of more advantaged pupils
they will loose a great opportunity to learn.
In the Mac OS X's Safari there is an option: Private Browsing that
will keep the browsing history private. Similar way there could be
option "private use" that would put the action to journal record so
that they are accessible only for the primary user.
I think this is how the Sugar could find balance between open learning
community and privacy . When someone wants privacy he or she may
"take" it and that is fine because it is an option ("right") provided
by the Sugar.
There has been some experimental work [3] to allow others to access
your Journal (and a way to choose a license [4] for each entry), but
nothing actually usable so far (AFAIK at least).
Thank you for the links. I find the "choosing license" quite silly
idea in the context of school learning, but that is another story. :-)
- Teemu
-----------------------------------------------
Teemu Leinonen
http://www.uiah.fi/~tleinone/
+358 50 351 6796
Media Lab
http://mlab.uiah.fi
Aalto University
School of Art and Design
-----------------------------------------------
_______________________________________________
IAEP -- It's An Education Project (not a laptop project!)
IAEP@lists.sugarlabs.org
http://lists.sugarlabs.org/listinfo/iaep
